Brigitte Boisselier

Template:Short description Template:Good article Template:Use dmy dates Template:Infobox person Brigitte Boisselier (born 1956), also known as Brigitte Roehr, is a French chemist and Raëlian religious leader best known for her claim to have overseen the creation of the first human clone. A native of Champagne-Ardenne, she studied chemistry in France and the United States, earning two PhDs. From 1984 to 1997, she lived near Paris and worked as a research chemist and a sales manager for Air Liquide. She embraced Raëlism in 1992; the group was unpopular in France and her conversion led to tensions with those around her. Five years later, she joined Clonaid, a Raëlian organization that sought to clone a human. After her service as their scientific director was publicized, she lost her position with Air Liquide and focused on cloning full-time.

In late 2000, Clonaid announced that they had received a large donation to fund the cloning of a child, and that Boisselier supervised a team of scientists at a secret laboratory in the United States who would soon produce a human clone. For the next year, the project received media coverage—and regulatory suspicion—as Boisselier promised the imminent birth of a human clone. In late 2001, she announced that one had been born and that public evidence would soon be offered. This declaration received significant press coverage in the United States, and Boisselier appeared on many television programs. After a court in Florida launched a child welfare investigation, she stated that the cloned child's parents had withdrawn their offer to provide evidence of the cloning and would have no further public comment. No evidence of the cloning, or subsequent procedures reported by Clonaid, was ever offered, and the announcements were widely perceived to have been a hoax.

In 2003, impressed with her management of Clonaid and public relations skill, Raël, the founder of Raëlism, announced that Boisselier would succeed him as the group's leader upon his death. In subsequent years, she has devoted herself to lecturing about the group's doctrines and serving as their spokesperson.

Early life and education

Brigitte Boisselier was born to a Catholic family in France in 1956.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn She was raised on a farm in Champagne-Ardenne and became interested in science while young.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn She attended the University of Dijon, earning a master's degree in biochemistry and a PhD in chemistry.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn In the 1980s, she moved to Texas, where she received another PhD in chemistry from the University of Houston.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn

Boisselier returned to France in 1984 to work for Air Liquide, an industrial gas company, where she remained for 13 years.Template:Sfn At that time, she lived in Les Loges-en-Josas and worked as a research chemist and a sales manager in Lyon.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Template:Sfn She married and had three children between the late 1970s and early 1990s.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Template:Sfn

Conversion and new career

In 1992, Boisselier converted to Raëlism, a UFO religion founded by the French journalist Claude Vorilhon, usually known as Raël.Template:Sfn After attending a meeting at which Raël spoke, she felt strongly that he was completely honest and joined his movement. Shortly before her conversion, she left her husband, alleging violent behavior. Template:Sfn Due to her increasing involvement with Raëlism, he gained sole custody of their youngest child soon afterwards.Template:Sfn Boisselier believed that religious intolerance motivated a court to transfer the child's custody. Although her faith led to tension with her parents,Template:Sfn her eldest child converted.Template:Sfn In the 1990s, Raëlism was seen as dangerous and viewed with disdain in France, resulting in loss of employment for prominent members.Template:Sfn The hostility was fueled in part by public concerns about new religious movements after deaths caused by the Order of the Solar Temple in Europe during the mid-1990s.Template:Sfn

Boisselier became the scientific director of Clonaid, an organization founded by Raël that sought to clone humans, in 1997.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn That year, Boisselier was interviewed by Le Monde about her role in Clonaid,Template:Sfn Template:Sfn and she lost her position with Air Liquide after the company learned of this.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Air Liquide stated that her termination was due to her holding dual employment,Template:Sfn and that she was strained by her Clonaid service.Template:Sfn She filed a lawsuit against Air Liquide, arguing that she was the victim of religious discrimination. Her suit was successful: in 1999, she won a judgment of about US$30,000.Template:Sfn

After losing her job, Boisselier moved with her middle child, a son, to Quebec, where her eldest daughter was a student.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Boisselier began to travel to discuss Clonaid,Template:Sfn eventually becoming a high-profile speaker.Template:Sfn Around that time, she reached the rank of Bishop within Raëlism.Template:Sfn She was one of the 25 members closest to Raël and joined the group's Order of Angels, which promoted free love and femininity.Template:Sfn She moved to the United States and began teaching at State University of New York at Plattsburgh for a short time before moving to Hamilton College in 2000 to teach chemistry.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Her association with Clonaid was publicized in the U.S. in February 2001, and she resigned her academic position that May, although she had a three-year contract.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn She claimed she was initially popular at Hamilton College, but felt that she was disrespected after her association with Clonaid was publicized.Template:Sfn

Cloning

Clonaid origins

Raël founded Clonaid in March 1997, shortly after the Dolly the Sheep cloning, believing that the process was important because the human species had been created by an extraterrestrial cloning project.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn On a practical level, Raël promoted the practice as a way to develop more desirable genetics and eventually prolong memories in new bodies.Template:Sfn Shortly after Clonaid's launch, Boisselier began publicizing and managing its operations. In 1999, she announced that she had set up cloning laboratories and had hired a team of six scientists.Template:Sfn She said she had limited knowledge of cloning but was skilled in selecting experts.Template:Sfn

In August 2000, Mark Hunt, a politician from West Virginia, asked Boisselier to clone his late son, who had died as a child. Hunt paid Clonaid $500,000 and helped them rent a science laboratory from a school.Template:Sfn Boisselier said that the laboratory would initially be used to clone cattle, before moving on to humans. She planned to use a number of Raëlian surrogates, who were willing to abort abnormal pregnancies, to bear clones; the high number of women would compensate for the low odds of a healthy child for each implantation.Template:Sfn In September 2000, Raël and Boisselier held a press conference with several aspiring surrogate mothers of clones. At the event, Boisselier announced the construction of a cloning laboratory and vaguely described Hunt, who wished to remain anonymous.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Boisselier received significant media attention as an advocate of cloning.Template:Sfn Some commentators initially accepted her work as a legitimate attempt at cloning; Margaret Talbot of the New York Times described her as a more credible spokesperson than Raël, projecting what she described as "an air of cool, academic professionalism".Template:Sfn Boisselier's striking physical appearance drew particular attention, and she developed an avant-garde, stylish reputation, contrary to popular images of scientists.Template:Sfn

Announcements and media coverage

File:Brigitte Boisselie 2001.png

Brigitte Boisselier at the United States House Committee on Energy and Commerce at March 2001.

In early 2001, Boisselier promised the cloning of a human child within a year,Template:Sfn drawing further attention to her work. A prosecutor in New York began investigating her compliance with local medical laws. Boisselier said that the Food and Drug Administration also surreptitiously investigated her,Template:Sfn and Raël claimed that U.S. President George W. Bush was concerned about Clonaid's work.Template:Sfn The caretaker of the laboratory that Hunt had rented grew suspicious about their work and contacted law enforcement. They spoke with the FDA, who searched the site and persuaded Boisselier to suspend her cloning work pending legal clarification.Template:Sfn After Hunt was asked by the laboratory's caretaker to shut down the cloning operation, he broke with Boisselier and criticized her for seeking media attention.Template:Sfn The caretaker also spoke publicly, saying that Boisselier was seldom at the laboratory.Template:Sfn Boisselier then announced that she was moving her cloning operations overseas. Boisselier never faced any legal charges in connection with the laboratory.Template:Sfn

In March 2001, Boisselier was invited to speak at a U.S. Congress hearing on human cloning, and at her insistence Raël was permitted to speak as well. The event garnered public attention, in large part because of Raël's unconventional appearance.Template:Sfn On 7 August 2001, Boisselier attended a widely publicized human cloning symposium at the National Academy of Sciences in Washington, D.C., Significant media attention was given to Boisselier, who, along with Severino Antinori and Panayiotis Zavos, was one of three participants actively engaged in efforts to produce a human clone.Template:Sfn The rest of the attendees were renowned scientists and ethicists, one of whom, Arthur Caplan, dismissed Boisselier as part of the "loony cloning element".Template:Sfn By May 2002, Boisselier said that she had facilitated 10 to 20 pregnancies but had been thwarted by miscarriages.Template:Sfn

Claims of success

File:Arthur Caplan (2667975697).jpg

Arthur Caplan, a bioethicist critic of Clonaid

Boisselier confidently announced at a press conference in Florida in December 2002 that Clonaid had successfully produced a live-born clone, named Eve, for an infertile couple.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Canadian sociologist Susan J. Palmer notes that naming the cloned child "Eve" recalls Raël's teachings that aliens created the first humans through cloning.Template:Sfn After the announcement, Boisselier received abundant press, but the media, particularly late-night comedy programs, criticized her glamorous appearance and mocked Raëlism.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn Around that time, Boisselier appeared on many U.S. network news broadcasts and on CNN.Template:Sfn She did not provide details about the child or its family, although she was often asked to.Template:Sfn She hired a science editor from ABC to supervise verification of the cloning.Template:Sfn Many scientists doubted that the Raëlians could overcome the difficulties that human cloning posed,Template:Sfn or that they would be able to produce a healthy child.Template:Sfn Boisselier said a DNA test was forthcoming and announced that five more clones would be born later that winter. As Raël and Boisselier continued to seek media exposure, journalistic animosity towards them grew.Template:Sfn

Bernard Siegel, an attorney from Florida, learned of the case and felt that a hearing should be held about Eve's welfare.Template:Sfn In January 2003, he initiated legal proceedings, seeking to bring the clone's parents to court so its health could be verified.Template:Sfn Raël and Boisselier attacked the filing as an attempt to take a child from loving parents and announced that, in protest, they would not provide DNA for testing.Template:Sfn An arraignment occurred on 24 January and was televised live on CNN; Boisselier and Clonaid's vice president, Thomas Kaenzig, were subpoenaed in lieu of the child's parents.Template:Sfn In courtroom testimony, the vice president of Clonaid said he knew very little about the clone, and that Boisselier controlled all the information.Template:Sfn She did not attend the hearing, and Kaenzig provided little information, angering the judge, who threatened contempt of court charges. Boisselier attended a second hearing on 29 January, telling the court that the child was in Israel. The judge then ruled that the court had no jurisdiction.Template:Sfn In late January, the science editor announced that he suspected the cloning announcements were a hoax.Template:Sfn Around that time, Boisselier held a press conference at which she announced that the cloned baby's parents had cut off contact with her and would never speak to the press.Template:Sfn

In the following years, Boisselier claimed to have facilitated the cloning of several children in a variety of countries. As of June 2004, she reported that Clonaid has successfully cloned 13 children. She did not provide evidence to verify the claims.Template:Sfn She stated that the machine called the RMX 2010 was used in the cloning attempts, and exhibited it publicly.Template:Sfn

After Boisselier announced that no evidence of the cloning would be provided, journalists became very skeptical of her story.Template:Sfn While discussing Boisselier's management of Clonaid, Palmer notes that it is impossible to know why she stated that a clone was produced but then refused to provide evidence. She argues that her refusal to provide evidence may have been because she organized a hoax, did not wish to publicize the birth of an unhealthy child, or was taken advantage of by a scientist she had hired.Template:Sfn American science journalist Steven S. Hall criticized the media for their coverage of Clonaid, believe that they were inaccurately represented as a credible group. He speculates that the coverage of Boisselier and other cloning adherents galvanized sentiment against cloning, leading to its banning in the U.S.Template:Sfn

Later activism

In January 2003, Raël held a ceremony at which he thanked Boisselier for her service and anointed her as his successor.Template:Sfn He praised her for spreading the message of Raëlism internationally while publicizing the cloning.Template:Sfn In the Raëlian hierarchy, she is one level below Raël and serves as a spokesperson for the movement.Template:Sfn Template:Sfn As a leader, she has attempted to rehabilitate the swastika, one of the group's symbols. She maintains that it is valuable as an ancient symbol of peace, and that it has been unfairly associated with Nazi Germany.Template:Sfn

In the mid-2000s, Boisselier often taught about the Raëlian perspective of the body and sexuality.Template:Sfn She discussed these topics from a biological perspective, arguing that humans are essentially robots because they can be reprogrammed. Specifically, she maintained that hormones program the brain, and they provide humans with the freedom to choose from many possibilities.Template:Sfn Raëlians emphasize sexual stimulation as a way to positively change their members,Template:Sfn and Boisselier has stated that she sees the pursuit of femininity as a method of spiritual growth.Template:Sfn The group highly values feminine beauty, and Raël has applauded Boisselier for maintaining her appearance, casting her as a role model.Template:Sfn

By 2007, Boisselier had taken the name "Brigitte Roehr" and was living in Los Angeles. That year, she began leading a Raëlian project to fight female genital mutilation. She heads a Raëlian-affiliated group known as Clitoraid, which raises funds to provide restorative surgery to women with damaged clitorises. The project, which has attracted criticism of its effectiveness, aims to build a hospital in Burkina Faso where women can receive clitoral surgery.Template:Sfn

References

Template:Reflist

Bibliography

Books

Newspapers

Template:Authority control Template:Raëlism