Editing Trance and Dance in Bali

{{short description|1952 anthropology film by Gregory Bateson, Margaret Mead}}
{{Use American English|date=January 2025}}
{{good article}}
{{italic title}}
[[File:Trance and dance in Bali Bateson Mead still 5.jpg|thumb|upright=1.35|In trance, the women dancers enter, holding their ''[[kris]]'' daggers aloft|alt=Film still showing women dancing with daggers]]
'''''Trance and Dance in Bali''''' is a short [[documentary film]] shot by the [[anthropologist]]s [[Margaret Mead]] and [[Gregory Bateson]] during their research on [[Bali]] in the 1930s. It shows female dancers with sharp ''[[kris]]'' daggers dancing in [[trance]], eventually stabbing themselves without injury. The film was not released until 1951. It has attracted praise from later anthropologists for its pioneering achievement, and criticism for its focus on the performance, omitting relevant details such as the conversation of the dancers.

== History ==

The [[anthropologist]]s [[Margaret Mead]] and [[Gregory Bateson]] visited [[Bali]] for two years of research in the 1930s, shooting some 22,000 feet of 16-millimetre film and 25,000 photographs, and completing seven films, of which ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' is one. They were married in 1936. Their output of visual materials has been described as unrivalled in anthropology.<ref name="Haley 2015"/><ref name="LoC on Mead">{{cite web |title=Margaret Mead: Human Nature and the Power of Culture |date=30 November 2001 |url=https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/mead/field-bali.html |publisher=[[Library of Congress]] |access-date=7 January 2022}}</ref> This was driven by their method of [[participant observation]], which was intended to be recorded in copious systematic field notes so as to grasp the subject's point of view.<ref name="Seckinger 1991">{{cite journal |last1=Seckinger |first1=Beverly |title=Filming Culture: Interpretation and Representation in Thence and Dance in Bali (1951), A Balinese Trance Seance (1980), and I t o on Jew: A Balinese Trance SeanceObserved (198 |journal=CVA Review (Commission on Visual Anthropology) |date=1991 |issue=Spring 1991 |pages=27–33 |url=https://vestiges-journal.info/CVA_Newsletter/cva_91_spring.pdf}}</ref> They paid careful attention to photographic technique, using both still and motion-picture cameras. During their stay, Bateson sent home for additional bulk film, a larger developing tank, and a rapid winder to allow photographs to be taken "in very rapid succession".<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/>

The dance for ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' was specially arranged during daylight hours, as no lighting equipment was available; the dance was, according to Mead, "ordinarily performed only late at night".<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/> Mead later<!--1972--> noted that "The man who made the arrangements decided to substitute young beautiful women for the withered old women who performed at night, and we could record how women who had never before been in [[trance]] flawlessly replicated the customary behavior they had watched all their lives".<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/> In this way, Mead justified the changes as part of their anthropological inquiry.<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/>

The film, like Bateson and Mead's other works, initially received a puzzled welcome. The films became classics, launched the field of [[visual anthropology]], and have "landmark status" with little to compare them to. Most of the footage of ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' was shot on 16 December 1937 in a performance that they commissioned (on Mead's birthday). They referenced their payment for the performance to Balinese cultural patronage. The trance ritual that they filmed was, according to the anthropologist [[Ira Jacknis]], "not an ancient form, but had been created during the period of their fieldwork", as a Balinese group had in 1936 "combined the Rangda or Witch play (Tjalonarang) with the [[Barong dance|Barong]] and kris-dance play, which was then popularized with tourists through the efforts of [the painter] [[Walter Spies]] and his friends."<ref name="Jacknis 1988">{{cite journal |last=Jacknis |first=Ira |title=Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson in Bali: Their Use of Photography and Film |journal=Cultural Anthropology |date=May 1988 |volume=3 |issue=2 |pages=60–177 |doi=10.1525/can.1988.3.2.02a00030 |jstor=656349}}</ref>

== Synopsis ==

[[File:Trance and dance in Bali Bateson Mead still 3.jpg|thumb|upright=1.35|The women [[ecstatic dance|dance ecstatically]], stabbing themselves with their razor-sharp ''kris'' daggers, and coming to no harm.|alt=Film still showing women dancers bending and writhing]]

The film describes and illustrates a single performance of the Kris Dance, a ritual dance on the Indonesian island of Bali. The dance portrays the struggle of good, in the shape of dragons, against evil, in the shape of masked ''Tjalonarang'' witches. The dancers are young women. They hold ''[[kris]]'' daggers. They are seen to enter trance, one at a time, and are revived from it. While in trance, they [[ecstatic dance|dance ecstatically]] and stab themselves with their daggers, remaining unharmed. 
The film opens and closes with displayed blocks of text, summarizing the dance's story.<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/>

No sounds were recorded at the time of filming. The film's soundtrack consists of narration by Mead, and Balinese music recorded elsewhere, possibly by Bateson and Mead's collaborators, the Canadian musicologist [[Colin McPhee]], and the scholar of Balinese dance Katherane Mershon.<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/>

== Publication ==

''Trance and Dance in Bali'' was filmed in the 1930s, most of it in 1937,<ref name="Jacknis 1988"/> and released in 1951. It is written and narrated by Mead, with cinematography by Bateson, and co-directed by Bateson and Mead. The short film is now available for free download.<ref name="Library of Congress"/>

== Historical significance ==

[[File:Trance and Dance in Bali.webm|thumb|upright=1.35|thumbtime=33|''Trance and Dance in Bali'' (22 minutes) |alt=Historic short anthropology film]]

In 1999 the film was deemed "[[culturally significant]]" by the United States [[Library of Congress]] and selected for preservation in the [[National Film Registry]].<ref name="Library of Congress">{{cite web |title=Trance and Dance in Bali |url=https://www.loc.gov/item/mbrs02425201/ |publisher=[[Library of Congress]] |access-date=17 October 2018 |ref=Mavis identifier: 2425201}}</ref>

The film was "very influential for its time", according to the anthropologist Jordan Katherine Weynand. She states that it records [[Balinese people]] "dancing while going through violent [[trance]]s, stabbing themselves with daggers without injury. They are then restored to consciousness with holy water and incense."<ref>{{cite web |last=Weynand |first=Jordan Katherine |title=Margaret Mead & Gregory Bateson |url=https://scholarblogs.emory.edu/visualanthropology/tag/trance-and-dance-in-bali/ |publisher=[[Emory University]] |access-date=17 October 2018 |date=8 September 2016 |archive-date=4 March 2021 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210304064110/https://scholarblogs.emory.edu/visualanthropology/tag/trance-and-dance-in-bali/ |url-status=dead }}</ref>

The Indonesian American anthropologist Fatimah Tobing Rony argues that the "photogenic" violence and trance are untranslatable: anthropology can look at trance but never really penetrates its mystery. In her view, "the naughty voices of the girls and the vain chuckles of the old women, transcribed by the secretary, are never heard in the voiceover or soundtrack: the women become undifferentiated exotic trancers. And the spiritual depths of the older women are not considered."<ref name="Rony 2006">{{cite journal |last=Rony |first=Fatimah Tobing |title=The Photogenic Cannot Be Tamed: Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson's ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' |journal=Discourse |date=2006 |volume=28 |issue=1 |pages=5–27 |jstor=41389738|doi=10.1353/dis.2008.0006|s2cid=143757682 }}</ref> As for [[Objectivity (science)|objectivity]], Rony remarks that "The photogenic ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' is representative of a kind of anthropological [[imperialist]] blindness, ironic considering that these scientists believed [in] and promoted the idea of their own superior vision".<ref name="Rony 2006"/>

The anthropologist Hildred Geertz calls the film pioneering, writing that Bateson and Mead are more than pathbreakers: their films "remain in certain crucial respects exemplary achievements."<ref name="Geertz 1976">{{cite journal |last=Geertz |first=Hildred |title=Trance and Dance in Bali. Gregory Bateson, Margaret Mead. ; Bathing Babies in Three Cultures. Gregory Bateson, Margaret Mead. ; Karba's First Years. Gregory Bateson, Margaret Mead. |journal=American Anthropologist |volume=78 |issue=3 |year=1976 |doi=10.1525/aa.1976.78.3.02a01160 |pages=725–726 |doi-access=free }}</ref> In her view, their films are sophisticated "even by today's standards in that they use film not as ethnographic illustration but as a powerful tool in systematic cultural research."<ref name="Geertz 1976"/> Geertz argues that ''Trance and Dance in Bali'' sets out a hypothesis about the interconnectedness of cultural experiences of childhood, ritual, and folk drama. The film is a "minute" sample of Mead's "incredibly large corpus of visual materials", now all archived and annotated. Geertz notes, too, that the film is "a highly dramatic and moving presentation of Balinese culture" that words alone could not achieve, even if the Witch-and-Dragon ritual dance had to be shot in daylight "rather than catching it in all its terrifying mystery" at night.<ref name="Geertz 1976"/>

The [[visual anthropologist]] Beverly Seckinger notes that the film created a visual record of one performance of the Kris Dance, with the minimum of written and voiced-over narration. She comments that the film was pioneering in focusing on one ritual, rather than attempting to show a whole "culture" (her quotation marks) in one film; and in limiting the amount of narration.<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/> She quotes Geertz's conclusion that "the
film remains an evocative and striking presentation of the way in which multiple
meanings are condensed within a centrally significant cultural form".<ref name="Geertz 1976"/> Seckinger remarks that all the same the film is "a product of its time", with not attempt to have the participants speak for themselves; she notes that without audio equipment, this would have been difficult. Further, the film treats the dancers as typical of Balinese culture, not as individuals, and there is no Balinese voice or quoted Balinese text. Instead, Mead's narration "inevitably takes on the character of 'scientific' authority".<ref name="Seckinger 1991"/>

The hypnotherapists [[Jay Haley]] and Madeleine Richeport-Haley describe the film as "a masterpiece of historical importance". They visited Bali around 50 years after Bateson and Mead, met some of the same people, and created a film with the title ''Dance and Trance of Balinese Children'', combining new footage with clips from ''Trance and Dance in Bali''.<ref name="Haley 2015">{{Cite journal |last1=Haley |first1=Jay |last2=Richeport-Haley |first2=Madeleine |year=2015 |title=Autohypnosis and Trance Dance in Bali |journal=International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis |volume=64 |issue=4 |pages=455–468 |doi=10.1080/00207144.2015.1062701 |pmid=26305133 |s2cid=41658040 }}</ref>

The scholar of film Trevor Ponech writes that by altering the customary conditions of performance, Bateson and Mead's objectivity is open to question, perhaps influenced by their "ethically questionable, lifeworld-distorting desires".<ref name="Ponech 2021">{{cite book |last=Ponech |first=Trevor |title=What is Non-Fiction Cinema? On the Very Idea of Motion Picture Communication |publisher=[[Routledge]] |publication-place=London |year=2021 |isbn=978-0-367-21341-1 |oclc=1285688409 |pages=11–14 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=qShHEAAAQBAJ&pg=PT17|doi=10.4324/9780429267499}}</ref>

==References==
{{reflist|2}}

==Further reading==
* {{cite book |last=Belo |first=Jane |title=Trance in Bali |publisher=[[Columbia University Press]] |year=1960 |isbn=978-0231944427 |doi=10.7312/belo94442 |ref=none}}

==External links==
{{commons category}}
*{{IMDb title|0221658}}

[[Category:1952 films]]
[[Category:United States National Film Registry films]]
[[Category:Anthropology documentary films]]
[[Category:American short documentary films]]
[[Category:Black-and-white documentary films]]
[[Category:1952 short documentary films]]
[[Category:Balinese culture]]
[[Category:Documentary films about dance]]
[[Category:American black-and-white films]]
[[Category:Articles containing video clips]]
[[Category:Films shot in Indonesia]]
[[Category:1950s dance films]]
[[Category:1950s American films]]