Editing Hlín

{{short description|Norse deity}}
[[File:Frigg by Doepler.jpg|thumb|"Frigg And Her Servants" (1882) by [[Carl Emil Doepler]].]]
In [[Norse mythology]], '''Hlín''' is a [[Áss|goddess]] associated with the goddess [[Frigg]]. Hlín appears in a poem in the ''[[Poetic Edda]]'', compiled in the 13th century from earlier traditional sources, the ''[[Prose Edda]]'', written in the 13th century by [[Snorri Sturluson]], and in [[kennings]] found in [[skald]]ic poetry. Scholars have debated whether the stanza referring to her in the ''Prose Edda'' refers to Frigg. ''Hlín'' serves as a given name in Iceland, and Hlín receives veneration in the modern era in Germanic paganism's modern extension, [[Heathenry (new religious movement)|Heathenry]].

==Etymology==
Scholars frequently explain the meaning behind the goddess's name as 'protector'.<ref name="PROTECTOR">See, for example, Orchard (1997:86) and Lindow (2001:177).</ref> The ''Prose Edda'' section ''Gylfaginning'' derives the name from a verb found in a [[proverb]] in an obscure and otherwise unattested Old Norse proverb: ''Þiaðan af er þat orðtak at sá er forðask hleinir''. Scholars generally accept that the theonym ''Hlín'' derives from the verb ''hleina''. However, the verb ''hleina'' in which the section claims a derivation is obscure (a ''[[hapax legomenon]]''), and translators have attempted to work around it in a variety of manners, in some cases leaving the verb untranslated. Examples include the translations of [[Anthony Faulkes]] ("From this comes the saying that someone who escapes finds refuge (''hleinir'')", 1995 [1987]) and [[Jesse Byock]] ("From her name comes the expression that he who escapes finds ''hleinir'' [peace and quiet]", 2005).<ref name="HOPKINS-2017-31-32-33">Hopkins (2017:31, 32–33).</ref>

Scholars have proposed a variety of derivations for the verb. The verb is most commonly linked to Old English ''hlinian'' and ''hlænan'', ancestors to the modern English verb ''lean''. 19th century scholars, including [[Jacob Grimm]], linked ''hleina'' to the rare Old Norse noun ''hlynr'', meaning '[[maple tree]]'. Grimm links this derivation to a variety of tree figures found in folklore from the modern era in northwest Europe. Joseph Hopkins (2017) comments that this derivation may deserve further investigation in light of the potential connection between the Old Norse goddess name ''[[Ilmr]]'' and the Old Norse common noun ''almr'' ([[Elm tree]]), and says that "the potential of a protective tree goddess brings to mind a mysterious passage in the ''Prose Edda'' involving the [[rowan]], in which the tree is referred to as [Thor's] ''bjǫrg'' ['aid, help, salvation, rescue']".<ref name="HOPKINS-2017-31-32-33-35">Hopkins (2017:31, 32–33, 35).</ref>

==Attestations==
In the ''Poetic Edda'' poem ''[[Völuspá]]'', Hlín receives a mention regarding the foretold death of the god [[Odin]] during the immense battle waged at [[Ragnarök]]:
<blockquote>
:Then is fulfilled Hlín's
:second sorrow,
:when Óðinn goes
:to fight with [[Fenrir|the wolf]],
:and [[Beli (jötunn)|Beli]]'s [[Freyr|slayer]],
:bright, against [[Surtr]].
:Then shall Frigg's
:sweet friend fall.<ref name=DRONKE21>Dronke (1997:21).</ref>
</blockquote>

The death of Odin (the stanza's "second sorrow") implies a first death. Scholars all but universally view this as a reference to the death of the god [[Baldr]], Frigg and Odin's son.<ref name="HOPKINS-2017-30">Hopkins (2017:30).</ref> Some translators replace the reference of Hlín to a mention of Frigg due to their interpretations of the stanza (see discussion in ''Scholarly reception and interpretation'' section below).<ref name="HOPKINS-31-32">Examples include translations by [[Olive Bray]] (1908), [[Carolyne Larrington]] (1999), [[Jeramy Dodds]] (2014), and [[Jackson Crawford]] (2015). For discussion, see Hopkins (2017:31–32).</ref>

In chapter 35 of the ''Prose Edda'' book ''[[Gylfaginning]]'', Hlín is listed twelfth among a series of sixteen goddesses. [[High, Just-As-High, and Third|High]] tells [[Gylfi|Gangleri]] (earlier in the book described as King [[Gylfi]] in disguise) that Hlín "is given the function of protecting people whom Frigg wishes to save from some danger." High continues that, from this, comes the saying that "someone who escapes finds refuge (''hleinar'')."<ref name=FAULKES30>Faulkes (1995:30).</ref> The verb ''hleina'' in this passage is obscure and has yielded a variety of translations (see ''etymology'' section above).<ref name="HOPKINS-2017-30"/>

In chapter 51, the above-mentioned ''Völuspá'' stanza is quoted.<ref name=FAULKES55>Faulkes (1995:55).</ref> In chapter 75 of the book ''[[Skáldskaparmál]]'' Hlín appears within a list of 27 ásynjur names.<ref name=FAULKES157>Faulkes (1995:157).</ref>

In [[skald|skaldic poetry]], the name Hlín is frequent in [[kenning]]s for women. Examples include ''Hlín hringa'' ('Hlín of rings'), ''Hlín goðvefjar'' ('Hlín of velvet') and ''arm-Hlín'' ('arm-Hlín'). The name is already used frequently in this way by the 10th-century poet [[Kormákr Ögmundarson]] and remains current in skaldic poetry through the following centuries, employed by poets such as [[Þórðr Kolbeinsson]], [[Gizurr Þorvaldsson]] and [[Einarr Gilsson]].<ref>Finnur Jónsson (1931:263).</ref> The name remained frequently used in woman kennings in [[rímur]] poetry, sometimes as '''Lín'''.<ref>Finnur Jónsson (1926) 28:175, 245).</ref>

In a verse in ''[[Hávarðar saga Ísfirðings]]'', the phrase ''á Hlín fallinn'' ("fallen on Hlín") occurs. Some editors have emended the line<ref>Gísli Brynjúlfsson (1860:174).</ref><ref>Finnur Jónsson (1912–1915a:191), (1912–1915b:181).</ref> while others have accepted the reading and taken Hlín to refer to [[Jörð|the earth]].<ref>Björn Karel Þórólfsson and Guðni Jónsson (1943:341).</ref>

==Modern influence==
In line with a cultural practice to use Old Norse theonyms as [[personal name]]s, ''Hlín'' appears as a given name for females in [[Iceland]]. Like other goddesses from the North Germanic corpus, Hlín receives veneration in [[Heathenry (new religious movement)|Heathenry]].<ref name="HOPKINS-2017-31">Hopkins (2017:31).</ref>

==Scholarly reception and interpretation==
Although the ''Prose Edda'' identifies Hlín as a separate goddess than Frigg, many scholars identify Hlín as another name for Frigg. For example, Andy Orchard says that in ''Völuspá'', Hlín appears to be just another name for Frigg, and adds that "the numerous occurrences of the name in skaldic poetry in poetic periphrases or kennings for women do nothing to dispel the confusion."<ref name=ORCHARD86>Orchard (1997:86).</ref> [[Rudolf Simek]] agrees that Hlín seems to appear as another name for Frigg in ''Völuspá'', and that in skaldic poetry Hlín was a well-known mythological figure by the 10th century. Simek states that Hlín is likely simply another name for Frigg, and that Snorri "misunderstood her to be a goddess in her own right in his reading of the ''Völuspá'' stanza."<ref name=SIMEK153>Simek (2007:153).</ref>

However, in the same work, Simek also says that the goddesses [[Sága]], Hlín, [[Sjöfn]], [[Snotra]], [[Vár]], and [[Vör]] should be considered vaguely defined figures who "should be seen as female protective goddesses" that are all responsible for "specific areas of the private sphere, and yet clear differences were made between them so that they are in many ways similar to [[Matres and Matrones|matrons]]."<ref name=SIMEK274>Simek (2007:274).</ref>

Some scholars express uncertainty at identifying Hlín as another name for Frigg, and others reject the identification altogether. In a 2017 paper on the topic, Hopkins agrees with Simek's comparison to the matrons and compares the scholarly reception of the goddess [[Fulla]], another goddess closely associated with Frigg, to that of Hlín:
<blockquote>
:"Like Hlín, the name ''Fulla'' ['full,  bountiful'] may be tempting to dismiss as a reading error on the part of a ''Prose Edda'' author or as a poetic invention ... Were it not for the preservation of the cognate theonym Volla in the [[Second Merseburg Charm]], Fulla would remain in a similarly ambiguous position like that of Hlín, easily overlooked, dismissed, or deconstructed ... the correlations between the ''Prose Edda'' and the Second Merseburg Incantation provide something of a cautionary tale: namely, by dismissing information found solely in the ''Prose Edda'', one risks violating the foundational maxim of ''absence of evidence is not evidence of absence''. There is no reason to doubt that Hlín was an independent entity in Old Norse mythology and no positive evidence to suggest that Hlín was merely a by-name of Frigg."<ref name="HOPKINS-34-35">Hopkins (2017:34–35).</ref>
</blockquote>
Referencing the iconography of the early Germanic matrons, Hopkins proposes an alternate reading of the ''Völuspá'' stanza in line with the ''Gylfaginning'' description of the goddess. In Hopkins's reading of the stanza, Hlín's sorrows are her inability to protect figures close to Frigg: the first sorrow would therefore be the death of Baldr, and the second sorrow the foretold death of Odin.<ref name="HOPKINS-35">Hopkins (2017:35).</ref>

==See also==
* [[Ilmr]], an Old Norse goddess whose name may mean 'elm tree'
* [[Sacred trees and groves in Germanic paganism and mythology]]

==Notes==
{{reflist|2}}

==References==
{{refbegin}}
* Björn Karel Þórólfsson and Guðni Jónsson (1943). ''Vestfirðinga sǫgur''. Reykjavík: Hið íslenzka fornritafélag.
* [[Ursula Dronke|Dronke, Ursula]] (Trans.) (1997). ''The Poetic Edda: Volume II: Mythological Poems''. [[Oxford University Press]]. {{ISBN|0-19-811181-9}}
* Faulkes, Anthony (Trans.) (1995). ''Edda''. [[Everyman's Library|Everyman]]. {{ISBN|0-460-87616-3}}
* [[Finnur Jónsson]] (1931). ''Lexicon Poeticum''. København: S. L. Møllers Bogtrykkeri.
* Finnur Jónsson (1926–28). ''Ordbog til de af samfund til udg. af gml. nord. litteratur udgivne rímur samt til de af Dr. O. Jiriczek udgivne bósarimur''. København: J. Jørgensen & Co.
* Finnur Jónsson (1912–1915). ''Den norsk-islandske skjaldedigtning'' A: ''Tekst efter håndskrifterne'', 2 vols. B: ''Rettet tekst'', 2 vols. København: Gyldendal.
* Gísli Brynjúlfsson (1860). ''Hávarðar saga Ísfirðings''. Kjøbenhavn.
* Hopkins, Joseph (2017). "Goddesses Unknown III: On the Identity of the Old Norse Goddess Hlín". ''[[RMN Newsletter]]'', No. 12-13, pp. 30–36. [[University of Helsinki]]. Online: [https://www.academia.edu/35370883/Goddesses_Unknown_III_On_the_Identity_of_the_Old_Norse_Goddess_Hl%C3%ADn].
* [[John Lindow|Lindow, John]] (2001). ''[https://books.google.com/books?id=KlT7tv3eMSwC Norse Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs]''. [[Oxford University Press]]. {{ISBN|0-19-515382-0}}
* Orchard, Andy (1997). ''Dictionary of Norse Myth and Legend''. [[Orion Publishing Group|Cassell]]. {{ISBN|0-304-34520-2}}
* [[Rudolf Simek|Simek, Rudolf]] (2007) translated by Angela Hall. ''Dictionary of Northern Mythology''. [[Boydell & Brewer|D.S. Brewer]]. {{ISBN|0-85991-513-1}}
{{refend}}

{{Norse mythology}}

{{Good article}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Hlin}}
[[Category:Ásynjur]]
[[Category:Frigg]]