Editing Theobald of Bec (section)

==Archbishop==

===Early years===
[[File:Great Seal of King Stephen.jpg|thumb|300px|Both sides of the seal of [[Stephen, King of England|Stephen]], from an engraving made in 1846]]
Theobald was consecrated on 8 January 1139 by the legate, Alberic of Ostia.<ref name=Bartlett401/> He went to Rome for his [[pallium]]<ref name=Barlow94/> and took part in the [[Second Council of the Lateran|Second Lateran Council]].<ref name=Barlow110>Barlow ''English Church'' pp. 110–112</ref> As archbishop his behaviour was less political in comparison to that of his main rival, Henry of Blois.<ref name=Appleby60/> Henry was appointed a [[papal legate]] on 1 March 1139,<ref name=BHOWinch>Greenway "Winchester: Bishops" ''Fasti Ecclesiae Anglicanae 1066–1300'': Volume 2: Monastic Cathedrals (Northern and Southern Provinces)</ref> which meant that Henry could now call church councils in England and had power equal to or exceeding that of Theobald.<ref name=Salt15>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 15–16</ref> Theobald swore fealty to Stephen upon his election to Canterbury, recognising Stephen as the king of England.<ref name=DNB/>

Soon after his election Theobald selected his brother Walter to be [[archdeacon]] of Canterbury, and in 1148 promoted him to be [[Bishop of Rochester]].<ref name=Bartlett411>Bartlett ''England Under the Norman and Angevin Kings'' p. 411</ref> Theobald attended the council held by Stephen in June 1139 that deprived [[Roger of Salisbury]], [[Bishop of Salisbury]], and his nephews [[Nigel (bishop of Ely)|Nigel]], [[Bishop of Ely]], and [[Alexander of Lincoln|Alexander]], [[Bishop of Lincoln]], of their castles.<ref name=Appleby72>Appleby ''Troubled Reign of King Stephen'' p. 72</ref> According to most historians, Theobald took little part in the controversy that followed the council, which eventually ended with Roger's death in 1139 and Nigel and Alexander's restoration to favour.<ref name=DNB/><ref name=Boll441>Bollerman and Nederman "King Stephen" ''Journal of Medieval History'' pp. 441–442</ref> Recently however, that view has been challenged by two historians who argue that Theobald took a more active role in the council. They base their view on a ''Vita'', or ''Life'' of the 12th-century mystic [[Christina of Markyate]], which narrates the events and gives a more central role to Theobald, instead of Henry of Blois, in challenging Stephen's arrest of the three bishops.<ref name=Boll441/>

===Civil war===

Theobald's actions in the next few years are intertwined with the history of Stephen's ascension to the throne. Following King [[Henry I of England|Henry I]]'s death in 1135 the succession was disputed between the king's nephews—Stephen and his elder brother, [[Theobald II, Count of Champagne]]—and Henry's surviving legitimate child [[Empress Matilda|Matilda]], usually known as the Empress Matilda because of her first marriage to the [[Holy Roman Emperor|German Emperor]], [[Henry V, Holy Roman Emperor|Henry V]]. King Henry's only legitimate son, [[William Adelin|William]], had died in 1120. After Matilda was widowed in 1125, she returned to her father, who married her to [[Geoffrey V, Count of Anjou|Geoffrey, Count of Anjou]]. All the magnates of England and Normandy were required to declare [[fealty]] to Matilda as Henry's heir, but when Henry I died, Stephen rushed to England and had himself crowned before either Theobald II or Matilda could react. The Norman barons accepted Stephen as Duke of Normandy, and Theobald II contented himself with his possessions in France. But Matilda was not resigned to the loss, and secured the support of the Scottish king, [[David I of Scotland|David]], her maternal uncle, and in 1138 the support of her half-brother, [[Robert, 1st Earl of Gloucester|Robert, Earl of Gloucester]], an illegitimate son of Henry I.<ref name=Huscroft71>Huscroft ''Ruling England'' pp. 71–73</ref>{{efn|Henry I had more than 20 illegitimate children.<ref name=HenryI41>Hollister ''Henry I'' p. 41</ref>}}

After the [[Battle of Lincoln (1141)|Battle of Lincoln]] in 1141, with Stephen in captivity in [[Bristol]], Theobald did not immediately join the Empress.  He claimed that he needed to talk to Stephen before switching his oath of fealty. After consulting in person with Stephen, he secured permission to accept the current conditions, and then joined Henry of Blois, who had switched sides, at Winchester in April for a [[Synod|legatine council]] held to depose Stephen and crown Matilda as queen. Attendance at the council was sparse however, and the Empress could not be crowned because she did not hold London.<ref name=Stephen52>Davis ''King Stephen'' p. 52</ref> After the unsuccessful attempt to crown Matilda, those gathered at Winchester had to flee before Stephen's forces; one of Matilda's chief supporters, her half-brother Robert of Gloucester, was captured. During their flight Theobald and his fellow bishops were robbed of their horses and ecclesiastical vestments. Theobald then took a leading part in the negotiations that led to the exchange of Robert for Stephen, which happened in November 1141. Henry of Blois, having switched sides again, then held another legatine council in Westminster, which reaffirmed Stephen as king. Theobald ceremonially crowned Stephen at Canterbury during the Christmas court held there.<ref name=Salt17>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 17–18</ref>

Matilda remained in England until 1148. The disorders were at their peak between 1142 and 1148, but her cause could never secure enough support to enable her to be crowned. Nor could Stephen decisively defeat Matilda's forces, which meant that England remained divided in allegiance between the two rivals. But while Matilda was in England, her husband Geoffrey was conquering Normandy, which he finally overran in 1144.<ref name=Huscroft74>Huscroft ''Ruling England'' pp. 74–75</ref>

===Difficulties with Henry of Blois===
[[File:Britishmuseumhenryofbloisplaque.jpg|thumb|300px|left|A medieval plaque depicting [[Henry of Blois]], dating from around 1150]]

Theobald's dealings with Henry of Blois, the [[Bishop of Winchester]], his [[suffragan bishop]], were strained because of Henry's position as papal legate. Henry supported the appointment of [[William of York|William FitzHerbert]] as Archbishop of York in 1141, which Theobald opposed.<ref name=Stephen101>Davis ''King Stephen'' pp. 101–103</ref> Although Theobald spoke out against the manner of election, he took little active part in the subsequent electoral disputes, which resulted eventually in the deposition of FitzHerbert and his replacement at York by [[Henry Murdac]].<ref name=Salt90>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 90–91</ref><ref name=BHOYork>Greenway "Archbishops" ''Fasti Ecclesiae Anglicanae 1066–1300'': Volume 6: York</ref> But in September 1143, Henry's legatine powers lapsed when Pope [[Pope Innocent II|Innocent II]], who had made the legatine appointment, died. [[Pope Celestine II|Celestine II]] was elected on 26&nbsp;September 1143, but he was an opponent of Stephen, and thus was not favourably inclined towards Stephen's brother Henry either. To secure appointment as legate, Theobald travelled to Rome in December 1143, arriving shortly before Celestine's death on 8 March 1144. Theobald was probably accompanied by Nigel, Bishop of Ely, and [[Roger de Clinton]], [[Bishop of Coventry]].<ref name=Salt19>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 19–22</ref> Before his death, Celestine forbade Theobald "to allow any change to be made in the position of the English crown, since the transfer of it had been justly denounced, and the matter was still under dispute".<ref name=Stephenquote62>Quoted in Davis ''King Stephen'' p. 62</ref> This became the papal policy, and was a significant change from the recognition of Stephen as king by Pope Innocent II soon after Stephen's coronation in 1135.<ref name=Stephen62>Davis ''King Stephen'' p. 62</ref> It essentially forbade Theobald from crowning any successor to Stephen, especially while Stephen was still alive.<ref name=Salt37>Saltman ''Theobald'' p. 37</ref>

After Celestine's death Theobald returned to England, stopping at [[St Denis Abbey]] in Paris to help [[Suger]], the abbot, consecrate the newly rebuilt abbey church and its altars. Theobald was the only bishop present at the ceremony whose diocese was not in France.<ref name=Salt19/>{{efn|This abbey was one of the first [[Gothic architecture|Gothic]] churches in Europe, and the consecration served the additional purpose of introducing the higher ecclesiastics of France to the new architectural style.<ref name=Kidson980>Kidson "Gervase, Becket, and William of Sens" ''Speculum'' p. 980</ref>}} Meanwhile, Henry of Blois had arrived in Rome and begun negotiations with the new pope, [[Pope Lucius II|Lucius II]], over the elevation of the bishopric of Winchester to an archbishopric. It appears that Lucius appointed a legate, Cardinal [[Icmar of Tusculum|Icmar]], the [[Bishop of Tusculum]], to travel to England and oversee the project, but Lucius died before anything was accomplished.<ref name=Salt19/>

===Disputes with Stephen===

Theobald was back in Paris in May 1147 to meet with the new pope, Eugene III; among the issues probably discussed was Theobald's dispute with [[Bernard (Bishop of St Davids)|Bernard of St Davids]]. Relations at this time between Theobald and Stephen seem to have been good,<ref name=Salt24>Saltman ''Theobald'' p. 24</ref> but when Eugene summoned the English bishops to the [[Council of Reims (1148)|Council of Rheims]] in April 1148 the king forbade all of them from attending except for three he nominated: [[Hilary of Chichester|Chichester]], [[Robert de Bethune|Hereford]] and [[William de Turbeville|Norwich]]. Despite having been specifically refused permission Theobald sneaked away in a fishing boat,<ref name=Stephen101/> presumably accompanied by [[Gilbert Foliot]], who attended the council with him.<ref name=Barlow99>Barlow ''English Church'' p. 99</ref> Theobald had a number of reasons for defying the king: chiefly his obedience to the pope's order commanding his attendance, but also to keep the papacy from favouring the newly elected Archbishop of York, Henry Murdac, in the disputes between York and Canterbury. Murdac was known to be close to his fellow Cistercian Eugene.<ref name=Matthew197>Matthew ''King Stephen'' pp. 197–201</ref>

Bethune, the Bishop of Hereford, died during the council, and Eugene nominated Foliot as his successor at Theobald's urging.<ref name=Crouch305>Crouch ''Reign of King Stephen'' p. 305</ref> One of the council's last acts was to suspend the non-attending bishops from their offices. The only English bishop specifically named was Henry of Blois, but the others who did not attend were presumably also suspended although not named. Henry of Blois was singled out for special handling, as the papacy ordered that he could not be reinstated by Theobald; Eugene reserved to himself the power to restore Henry.  Theobald appears to have reinstated most of the bishops quickly, as Foliot wrote later in 1148 that only the bishops of Winchester, Durham, Worcester, Bath and Exeter were still suspended. Theobald forgave the bishops of Exeter, Worcester and Bath on 11&nbsp;November 1148, according to the later chronicler [[Gervase of Canterbury]]. Gervase also lists Hilary of Chichester as one of those forgiven by Theobald on that date, but as Hilary attended the council it is likely that this is an error. Durham may have been omitted because he was a suffragan bishop of the Archbishop of York, and his reinstatement was in his archbishop's hands.<ref name=Salt26>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 26–27</ref>

The king was angry with Theobald for attending the council, even though the archbishop intervened with Eugene, who was displeased with the king for forbidding the bishops' attendance. Theobald persuaded Eugene against excommunicating Stephen, asking the pope to allow the king to make amends for his behaviour. But Stephen was unimpressed with Theobald's intercession; he confiscated Theobald's property and banished the archbishop. In September 1148, the pope put England under [[Interdict (Catholic canon law)|interdict]], which was ignored except in Canterbury.<ref name=Stephen101/> At first Theobald was in exile at [[Saint-Omer|St Omer]], where he consecrated Gilbert Foliot as [[Bishop of Hereford]].<ref name=Salt28>Saltman ''Theobald'' p. 28</ref> He then returned to England and set himself up in [[Framlingham]], which was held by [[Hugh Bigod, 1st Earl of Norfolk|Hugh Bigod]], an adherent of the Empress. From there he conducted the ecclesiastical business of England, but Theobald's presence in the country posed a threat to Stephen's authority, and Stephen quickly settled the differences between the two.<ref name=Stephen101/>

Henry of Blois had lost his legateship before Celestine became pope, but it was not until about 1150 that Theobald was appointed legate by Eugene III, perhaps owing to the exhortations of [[Bernard of Clairvaux]].<ref name=Barlow110/> Theobald held the legatine powers in England until his death in 1161.<ref name=Bartlett411/> In 1151 Theobald held a [[Synod|legatine council]] in London.<ref name=Barlow131>Barlow ''English Church'' p. 131</ref> The council was attended by the king and [[Eustace IV of Boulogne|Eustace]], the king's eldest son, as well as other members of the nobility. The council decreed eight canons, or ecclesiastical statutes, including ones condemning the pillaging of church properties and the imposition of financial levies on the clergy.<ref name=DNB/> Another canon of the council stated that bishops should no longer pursue violators of church property in the royal courts, but should use ecclesiastical courts instead. The other canons dealt with procedural matters arising from excommunications for abusing church property.<ref name=Barlow131/>

The next year, the archbishop refused to crown Eustace and was again exiled by Stephen,<ref name=Norman273>Crouch ''Normans'' p. 273</ref> who was attempting to secure the succession for his son by imitating the [[Capetian dynasty]] of France, which usually saw the king's heir crowned during his father's lifetime.<ref name=DNB/> Although Theobald claimed papal authority for refusal, based on the prohibition by Celestine, it was more probable that he and the bishops had no desire to prolong the civil war.<ref name=Huscroft135>Huscroft ''Ruling England'' p. 135</ref> Stephen demanded in April 1152 that Theobald crown Eustace, but the archbishop once again refused, and went into exile in Flanders.<ref name=DNB/> Theobald claimed that Stephen had gained the throne through perjury, implying that if the archbishop crowned Eustace, Theobald would be perpetuating this crime.<ref name=Leedom354>Leedom "English Settlement" ''History'' p. 354</ref> The king and the archbishop reached a truce in August.<ref name=DNB/>

In January 1153 [[Henry II of England|Henry of Anjou]], Matilda's son, invaded England in pursuit of his claim to the throne, and with the death of Eustace in August 1153, Stephen gave up.<ref name=Huscroft74/> Theobald was instrumental in the negotiations between Henry and Stephen that resulted in the [[Treaty of Wallingford]], securing Henry's succession to the throne.<ref name=Barlow100/> Theobald was also present when Henry of Anjou met with Stephen's second son [[William I, Count of Boulogne|William]], probably after Eustace's death, to settle William's lands and status after Henry succeeded Stephen.<ref name=Amt16>Amt ''Accession of Henry II'' p. 16</ref> Pope Eugene III forced Stephen to reverse the sentence of banishment, and Theobald returned to his see.<ref name=Barlow100>Barlow ''English Church'' pp. 100–102</ref> Later it was mainly Theobald and Henry of Blois who negotiated the treaty ending the civil war, as neither Stephen nor Henry of Anjou was interested in a compromise.<ref name=Stephen118>Davis ''King Stephen'' p. 118</ref> Henry of Blois and Theobald, who had previously found working together difficult, managed to secure an end to the disorders in England.<ref name=Amt13>Amt ''Accession of Henry II'' p. 13</ref>

===Under Henry II===
Theobald was present at Stephen's deathbed in October 1154, and Stephen named him as regent until Henry could take up the crown.<ref name=Norman278>Crouch ''Normans'' p. 278</ref> During the six weeks before Henry arrived, the archbishop had little difficulty in keeping the peace.<ref name=Amt21>Amt ''Accession of Henry II'' p. 21</ref> After Henry's arrival, Theobald crowned Henry and his wife [[Eleanor of Aquitaine]] on 19 December 1154<ref name=Warren53>Warren ''Henry II'' p. 53</ref><ref name=Powell73>Powell and Wallis ''House of Lords'' p. 73</ref> at [[Westminster Abbey]].<ref name=Warren53/>

For most of the remainder of Theobald's life he was occupied with ecclesiastical affairs in his diocese, as well as attending the royal court when Henry was in England.<ref name=Salt41/> In January 1155 Theobald helped to secure the [[Lord Chancellor of England|Chancellorship]] for his protégé, Thomas Becket, an action that Barlow speculates happened because Theobald hoped to secure more influence with the king through Becket. If this was his hope, Barlow notes that it did not materialise. Although the king and the archbishop occasionally clashed when their interests conflicted, both appear to have wished to minimise the disputes and were willing to compromise to secure good relations.<ref name=DNB/> As an example, when Pope [[Pope Adrian IV|Adrian IV]] died in September 1159, two rival claimants for the papal throne emerged. King Henry, following the custom of his grandfather Henry I, forbade the bishops from recognising either claimant.<ref name=Salt41>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 41–45</ref> Eventually, after Henry weighed the political factors, he recognised Pope [[Pope Alexander III|Alexander III]], and it was only then that Theobald also recognised Alexander as pope.<ref name=Salt51>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 51–52</ref>

However, not everything was always harmonious between the king and the archbishop. In 1156, Theobald supported the efforts of [[Osbert de Bayeux]], who was accused of poisoning [[William of York|William]] the Archbishop of York, to secure a trial for his alleged crimes in an [[ecclesiastical court]] rather than in the royal court. The crime had taken place during Stephen's reign, but Stephen's death had prevented Osbert from being tried in 1154. The delay allowed the [[Benefit of clergy|shifting of the trial]] to the church courts, which Henry opposed. Although Theobald's position displeased the king no open rupture ensued.<ref name=Alexander2>Alexander "Becket Controversy" ''Journal of British Studies'' pp. 2–4</ref> Theobald himself admitted to the papacy in 1154 that English custom was to try clergy for crimes in the secular courts.<ref name=Alexander12>Alexander "Becket Controversy" ''Journal of British Studies'' p. 12</ref>

Theobald called a church council at London in June 1160, which dealt partly with the issues of the papal schism; his health was poor and he had to be taken to the council in a litter. A further cause of distress to Theobald was what he saw as the ingratitude of Becket, who did not visit the ailing archbishop.<ref name=DNB/>

===Relations with his cathedral clergy===

Theobald's [[cathedral chapter]] was composed of monks, and he was considered the abbot of the monastery of [[Christ Church, Canterbury|Christ Church Cathedral]]. Because of his episcopal duties, the regular running of the cathedral was the responsibility of the prior. At the time of Theobald's election there were about 140 monks in the chapter, and they seem to have expected that Theobald, being a monk himself, would take their side in disputes and continue to support their needs. Theobald began well, sending a party of monks from the cathedral to [[Dover Priory|St Martin's Priory]] at Dover, which had been settled with [[canon (priest)|canons]] instead of monks. Theobald replaced the canons with the monks.<ref name=Salt56/> Theobald also refounded a collegiate church at South Malling near [[Lewes]] to provide [[benefice]]s for his cathedral chapter.<ref name=Fonge78>Fonge "Patriarchy and Patrimony" ''Foundations of Medieval English Ecclessiastical History'' p. 78</ref>

Theobald worked with his first prior, Jeremiah, to eliminate clerical marriage in the diocese. But Jeremiah had been elected during the vacancy before Theobald's election, and the monks had not secured papal permission for the election of a new prior, so eventually Theobald decided to remove Jeremiah and install his own choice as prior. Jeremiah appealed to the papacy, but Theobald deposed him while the appeal was ongoing, and appointed [[Walter Durdent]] as prior. Innocent II, however, appointed Henry of Blois to hear the case, and Henry sided with Jeremiah and ordered Jeremiah's reinstatement.  Theobald then refused to perform any services in the cathedral until Jeremiah was removed by the chapter. The lack of services would have deprived the monks of income, and Theobald's threat had the desired effect, as Jeremiah resigned his office and left Christ Church for [[St Augustine's Abbey, Canterbury]]. Durdent was reinstalled as prior and remained in that position until he became Bishop of Coventry in October 1149.<ref name=Salt56>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 56–59</ref>

At Easter, 1151, Theobald took over the management of the chapter's estates, as the new prior, Walter Parvus, was not up to the task. At first, there were no disputes, but soon the monks felt that Theobald was cheating them and imposing too rigorous a definition of poverty, and asked that the stewardship of the estates be restored to Parvus. Theobald refused and the monks attempted to appeal to the papacy. Their envoys, however, were caught by agents of the archbishop and the appeal went nowhere. Theobald then deposed Parvus and appointed a new prior. Theobald's relations with the monks after this point seem to have been without incident.<ref name=Salt59>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 59–62</ref>

===Relations with other monastic houses===
[[File:Staugustinescanterburyrotundanaveandcathedral.jpg|upright|220px|left|Ruins of [[St Augustine's Abbey]], with Canterbury Cathedral behind|thumb]]
Theobald also had a dispute with St Augustine's Abbey over the right of the archbishop to receive annual payments, and whether those payments were for sacraments performed by the archbishop, which would have been uncanonical, or were for other reasons. The dispute was eventually settled by a compromise in which St Augustine's continued to make the payments but they were specifically stated not to be for sacraments.<ref name=Salt66>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 66–69</ref> Another dispute with St Augustine's concerned the right of the archbishops to have a say in the election of new abbots and whether or not the abbots would make a profession of obedience to the archbishops. This was eventually settled by a papal mandate of 1144 instructing the abbots to profess obedience.<ref name=Salt73>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 73–75</ref>

The conflict re-surfaced in 1149, when some of the monks of St Augustine's, led by their prior and sacrist, refused to obey the interdict placed on England by Theobald and Pope Eugene III. Theobald had the two officials excommunicated and publicly flogged. When the previous abbot of St Augustine's died in 1151, the prior, Silvester, paid the king for the right to administer the abbey and to hold a free election for a new abbot. The monks then proceeded to elect Silvester as the new abbot, but Theobald refused to confirm the election, accusing Silvester of buying the office. Eventually, however, Pope Eugene III ordered Theobald to allow Silvester to take up the office, which Theobald did in August 1152.<ref name=DNB/> Theobald and St Augustine's also came into conflict over the abbey's claims of exemption from the archbishops' oversight, because it owed obedience directly to the pope. Papal documents held at Rome backed the abbey, but there were no English royal charters that gave the abbey its liberty from the archbishops. Theobald attempted to end the confusion by legal actions both at Rome and in England, but the record was mixed. The documents at Rome clearly favoured the abbey, but at a royal council held at [[Northampton]] in 1157, Henry II ruled in favour of Theobald.<ref name=Monastic588/> As part of the settlement Silvester, as abbot, was required to make a formal profession of obedience to Theobald, something he had been attempting to avoid since his election.<ref name=Lanfranci157>Hayward "Some Reflections" ''Historical Research'' p. 157</ref> The struggle with Silvester was just one event in the long history of the dispute between Canterbury and St Augustine's.<ref name=Monastic588>Knowles ''Monastic Order'' p. 588</ref>

As well as St Augustine's, the abbots of a number of other monasteries in the diocese of Canterbury are known to have professed obedience to Theobald, as the documents recording the events survive. Not only abbots and priors from within Canterbury, but some from other dioceses swore to obey Theobald, although normally such oaths would have gone to their diocesan bishop instead. Most of these exceptions occurred because the monastic house claimed exemption from the oversight of their diocesan bishop, and had a tradition of making those oaths to Canterbury instead. Besides these events, Theobald also intervened in the elections of some abbots, although not always successfully. He attempted to secure the right of Gilbert Foliot to remain [[Abbot of Gloucester]] after Foliot's election as Bishop of Hereford, but a new abbot was elected by the monks of Gloucester. Theobald was more successful in securing the election of William, who had previously been a monk at Christ Church, to be [[Abbot of Evesham]] over the objections of some of the monks of Evesham.<ref name=Salt81>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 81–85</ref>

Theobald also became embroiled in the dispute between Hilary, the Bishop of Chichester, and [[Walter de Lucy]], the abbot of [[Battle Abbey]], over Hilary's claims to jurisdiction over the abbey and the abbey's counter-claims that it was exempt from episcopal supervision. The abbey had never received a papal exemption, but relied instead on its royal foundation by King [[William I of England]] and its status as an [[Proprietary church|eigenkirche]], or proprietary church of the king.<ref name=HenryII429>Warren ''Henry II'' pp. 429–432</ref> Under King Stephen, the abbey's claims prevailed, but after Stephen's death Hilary excommunicated the abbot, who appealed to the papacy. Theobald supported the bishop, who eventually secured a trial before King Henry II. It was a minor setback for Theobald when the case was eventually decided in Battle's favour, mainly on the basis of charters that were thought at the time to be genuine, but modern historians have come to believe were forged.<ref name=Searle>Searle "Battle Abbey" ''English Historical Review'' pp. 449–480</ref>

===Relations with other bishops===

Theobald was instrumental in securing the subordination of the Welsh bishoprics to Canterbury. His first act in this area was the consecration of [[Meurig (bishop)|Meurig]] as [[Bishop of Bangor]] in 1140, during which Meurig made a profession of obedience like those made by other bishops subject to Canterbury.<ref name=Salt92/> [[Bernard (Bishop of St Davids)|Bernard]], [[Bishop of St&nbsp;Davids]], contested Theobald's right to consecrate Meurig and instead asserted that St&nbsp;Davids should be considered an archbishopric, and that Bernard should receive a pallium. This went against the last half-century of precedent that Canterbury had jurisdiction over the four Welsh sees, a precedent that dated back to Anselm's days when Anselm had consecrated [[Urban (bishop of Llandaff)|Urban]] as [[Bishop of Llandaff]] in 1107.<ref name=Lawrence101/>

Also in 1140, Theobald consecrated [[Uhtred (Bishop of Llandaff)|Uhtred]] as Bishop of Llandaff, with Uhtred also swearing to obey Theobald. Likewise, when Theobald consecrated [[Gilbert (Bishop of St Asaph)|Gilbert]] as [[Bishop of St&nbsp;Asaph]] in 1142, a similar profession of obedience was made.<ref name=Salt92>Saltman ''Theobald'' pp. 92–94</ref> Along with these consecrations, Theobald's legal efforts enabled him to withstand the attempts of Bernard to turn St&nbsp;Davids into an archbishopric, and when Bernard was succeeded by [[David fitzGerald]] in 1148, Theobald secured the new bishop's profession of obedience to Canterbury, thus ending the efforts to remove Wales from Canterbury's jurisdiction.<ref name=DNB/> Also in 1148, Pope Eugene decided in favour of Canterbury and against the claims of St&nbsp;Davids, securing Canterbury's jurisdiction over Wales.<ref name=Lawrence101>Duggan "From the Conquest to the Death of John" ''English Church and the Papacy'' pp. 101–102</ref>

Theobald even maintained the theoretical claim of Canterbury to jurisdiction over Irish sees by consecrating Patrick as [[Bishop of Limerick]] in 1140.<ref name=Salt95>Saltman ''Theobald'' p. 95</ref> That, however, was the last assertion of the claim, as in 1152 the papal legate [[Giovanni Paparo]] reorganised the Irish dioceses and settled the issue by appointing the [[Archbishop of Armagh]] the [[Primate (bishop)|primate]] of Ireland.<ref name=DNB/>

Relations with bishops in England remained good, with little activity in the long-running [[Canterbury–York dispute]] over the primacy of Britain. Theobald obtained a vague confirmation of his see's primacy from Celestine II in 1143–1144, but at the [[Council of Reims]] in 1148 Eugene clarified that this primacy did not affect the claims of York to be independent of Canterbury. Because of the unsettled election disputes during the 1140s over the see of York, when it was contested between William of York and Henry Murdac, Theobald faced little challenge from either William or Murdac as to the traditional dispute between Canterbury and York. When William of York died in 1154, Theobald secured York for his protégé, [[Roger de Pont L'Evêque]]. Further peace between the two sees was ensured when Theobald consecrated Roger without requiring a profession of obedience, which had previously been a major bone of contention between the two.<ref name=DNB/>

===Patronage and household===

[[File:Canterbury Cathedral 011 Medieval glass Thomas a Becket.JPG|thumb|upright|Medieval stained-glass window depicting [[Thomas Becket]]|220px]]
Theobald's household included many young men of ability, including his successor [[Thomas Becket]]. Theobald was instrumental in the early spread of Roman law to England, inviting the Bologna-schooled jurist [[Vacarius]] to join his administration and advise on legal matters.<ref>Helmholz ''Oxford History of the Laws of England'' '''1''' p. 121</ref><ref name=Lyon186>Lyon ''Constitutional and Legal History of Medieval England'' p. 186</ref> Whether Vacarius actually started a school in Theobald's household is unclear, but in the 1140s he taught briefly at Oxford.<ref name=Roman6>Turner "Roman Law" ''Journal of British Studies'' p. 6</ref> Theobald was instrumental in fostering the teaching of canon law in England; the conflict that later arose between Henry II and Thomas Becket had its roots in disputes that were exposed during Theobald's time in office.<ref name=Lawrence85>Duggan "From the Conquest to the Death of John" ''English Church and the Papacy'' pp. 85–88</ref> While still in Normandy, Theobald had made an intense study of ecclesiastical or canon law, which he continued after being elected archbishop.<ref name=Monastic516>Knowles ''Monastic Order'' p. 516</ref>

Although Theobald was a monk, his episcopal household was not monastic in character. As he settled into the role of archbishop, he seems to have left most of his monastic habits behind, although he continued to have a monk as a companion. His nephews and brother benefited from his [[nepotism]],<ref name=Becket32>Barlow ''Thomas Becket'' p. 32</ref> with his nephews becoming part of his household early in his archiepiscopate. The four nephews—Guillaume, Gilbert, Roger and Lechard—were witnesses to a charter of Theobald's dated to about 1150 or 1153. After Theobald's death, Guillaume was a clerk in [[Bartholomew Iscanus|Bartholomew]], the [[Bishop of Exeter]]'s household in around 1172.<ref name=DNB/>

Another charter of Theobald's from about 1152 shows the usual household staff that surrounded him. It was witnessed by the archbishop's crossbearer, three of Theobald's nephews and the clerk who presumably was in charge of them, a [[chancellor]], two chaplains who were monks, a butler, dispenser, [[chamberlain (office)|chamberlain]], steward, cook, usher, porter and [[marshal]].<ref name=DuBoulay252>DuBoulay ''Lordship of Canterbury'' p. 252</ref> Theobald also at about the same time granted a mill to his baker named William and some lands to his cook William and the cook's heirs.<ref name=DuBoulay258>DuBoulay ''Lordship of Canterbury'' p. 258</ref>

Theobald was the patron of three eminent men: Becket, Vacarius, and [[John of Salisbury]].<ref name=Barlow38>Barlow ''English Church'' p. 38</ref> John of Salisbury was secretary to Theobald for many years, and after Theobald's death became [[Bishop of Chartres]]. It was during John's time as secretary that he wrote his two most famous works, the ''[[Policraticus]]'' and the ''[[Metalogicon]]''.<ref name=SaulJohn>Saul "John of Salisbury" ''Companion to Medieval England'' pp. 150–151</ref> Others who studied for a time in Theobald's household were Roger de Pont L'Evêque, later Archbishop of York, [[John of Canterbury|John Belemis]], later [[Archbishop of Lyons]],<ref name=Poole196>Poole ''Domesday Book to Magna Carta'' p. 196</ref> [[John de Pageham]], later [[Bishop of Worcester]], Bartholomew Iscanus, later Bishop of Exeter, [[William of Northall]], later Bishop of Worcester, and [[William de Vere]], later Bishop of Hereford.<ref name=Becket30>Barlow ''Thomas Becket'' pp. 30–31</ref> In all, his household produced three archbishops and six bishops. The household itself, although not formally a school, acted as one, with many going on to careers in the church.<ref name=DNB/>