Editing Jonathan Edwards (theologian) (section)

==Later years==

In 1748, there had come a crisis in his relations with his congregation. The [[Half-Way Covenant]], adopted by the synods of 1657 and 1662, had made [[baptism]] alone the condition to the civil privileges of church membership, but not of participation in the [[sacrament]] of the [[Eucharist|Lord's Supper]]. Stoddard had been even more liberal, holding that the Lord's Supper was a converting ordinance and that baptism was a sufficient title to all the privileges of the church.{{Sfn |Gardiner|Webster |1911 |p=4}}

As early as 1744, Edwards, in his sermons on ''Religious Affections'', had plainly intimated his dislike of this practice. In the same year, he had published in a church meeting the names of certain young people, members of the church, who were suspected of reading improper books, and also the names of those who were to be called as witnesses in the case. It has often been reported{{By whom|date=January 2025}} that the witnesses and accused were not distinguished on this list, and so the entire congregation was in an uproar. However, Patricia Tracy's research has cast doubt on this version of the events, noting that in the list he read from, the names were definitely distinguished. Those involved were eventually disciplined for disrespect to the investigators rather than for the original incident. In any case, the incident further deteriorated the relationship between Edwards and the congregation.<ref>{{Cite book|last=Tracy|first=Patricia J.|title=Jonathan Edwards, Pastor: Religion and Society in Eighteenth Century Northampton|publisher=Wipf & Stock Publishers |year=2006 |isbn=978-1-59752-612-8 |location=Eugene |orig-year=1980}}</ref>{{Page needed|date=July 2021}}

Edwards's preaching became unpopular. For four years, no candidate presented himself for admission to the church, and when one eventually did, in 1748, he was met with Edwards's formal tests as expressed in the {{Citation | title = Distinguishing Marks}} and later in {{Citation | title = Qualifications for Full Communion | year = 1749}}. The candidate refused to submit to them, the church backed him, and the break between the church and Edwards was complete. Even permission to discuss his views in the pulpit was refused. He was allowed to present his views on Thursday afternoons. His sermons were well attended by his fans but not his own congregation. A council was convened to decide the communion matter between the minister and his people. The congregation chose half the council, and Edwards was allowed to select the other half of the council. His congregation, however, limited his selection to one county where the majority of the ministers were against him. The ecclesiastical council voted by 10 to 9 that the pastoral relation be dissolved.{{Sfn |Gardiner|Webster |1911 |p=4}}

The church members, by a vote of more than 200 to 23, ratified the action of the council, and finally a town meeting voted that Edwards should not be allowed to occupy the Northampton pulpit, though he continued to live in the town and preach in the church by the request of the congregation until October 1751. In his "Farewell Sermon" he preached from 2 Corinthians 1:14 and directed the thoughts of his people to that far future when the minister and his people would stand before God. In a letter to Scotland after his dismissal, he expresses his preference for [[Presbyterian polity|Presbyterian]] to [[congregational polity]]. His position at the time was not unpopular throughout New England. His doctrine that the Lord's Supper is not a cause of regeneration and that communicants should be professing Protestants has since (largely through the efforts of his pupil [[Joseph Bellamy]]) become a standard of New England Congregationalism.{{Sfn |Gardiner|Webster |1911 |p=4}}

Edwards was in high demand. A parish in Scotland could have been procured for him, and he was called to a Virginia church.{{cn|date=February 2024}} He declined both of these to become pastor in 1751 of the church in [[Stockbridge, Massachusetts|Stockbridge]], Massachusetts and a missionary to the [[Housatonic River|Housatonic]] Indians,<ref>{{Cite web |date=2023-03-18 |title=Jonathan Edwards - Dismissal from Northampton of Jonathan Edwards |url=https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jonathan-Edwards/Dismissal-from-Northampton |access-date=2023-05-20 |publisher=[[Encyclopedia Britannica]] |language=en}}</ref> taking over for the recently deceased [[John Sergeant (missionary)|John Sergeant]]. To the Indians, he preached through an interpreter, and their interests he boldly and successfully defended, by attacking the whites who were using their official positions among them to increase their private fortunes. During this time he got to know Judge [[Joseph Dwight]] who was trustee of the Indian Schools. In Stockbridge, he wrote the ''Humble Relation'', also called ''Reply to Williams'' (1752), which was an answer to Solomon Williams, a relative and a bitter opponent of Edwards as to the qualifications for full communion. He composed the treatises on which his reputation as a philosophical theologian chiefly rests, the essay on [[Original sin|Original Sin]], the ''Dissertation Concerning the Nature of True Virtue'', the ''Dissertation Concerning the End for which God created the World'', and the great work on the ''Will'', written in four and a half months and published in 1754 under the title, ''An Inquiry into the Modern Prevailing Notions Respecting that Freedom of the Will which is supposed to be Essential to Moral Agency''.{{Sfn |Gardiner|Webster |1911 |p=4}}

[[Aaron Burr Sr.]], Edwards' son-in-law, died in 1757 (he had married Esther Edwards five years before, and they had made Edwards the grandfather of [[Aaron Burr]], later U.S. vice president). Edwards felt himself in "the decline of life", and inadequate to the office, but was persuaded to replace Burr as president of the College of New Jersey (now [[Princeton University]]). He was installed on February 16, 1758. He gave weekly essay assignments in theology to the senior class.{{Sfn|Leitch|1978|p=|pp=151–152}}