Editing Diabelli Variations (section)

== Diabelli's theme ==
Whether Schindler's story is true or not that Beethoven at first contemptuously dismissed Diabelli's waltz as a ''Schusterfleck'' (''rosalia'' / "cobbler's patch"), there is no doubt the definition fits the work perfectly – "musical sequences repeated one after another, each time modulated at like intervals" – as can be seen clearly in these three examples:

# [[File:schusterfleck1.jpg]] 
# {{examples|date=April 2017}}
# [[File:schusterfleck3.jpg]]

From the earliest days writers have commented on the juxtaposition between the waltz's simplicity and the vast, complex musical structure Beethoven built upon it, and the widest possible range of opinions of Diabelli's theme have been expressed. At one end of the spectrum is the admiration of [[Donald Tovey]] ("healthy, unaffected, and drily energetic", "rich in solid musical facts", cast in "reinforced concrete"<ref>{{Harvnb|Tovey|1944|pp=125–27}}</ref>) and [[Maynard Solomon]] ("pellucid, brave, utterly lacking in sentimentality or affectation"{{citation needed|date=September 2010}}) and the kindly tolerance of [[Hans von Bülow]] ("quite a pretty and tasteful little piece, protected from the dangers of obsolescence by what one might call its melodic neutrality").{{citation needed|date=September 2010}} At the other end is [[William Kinderman]]'s contempt ("banal", "trite", "a beer hall waltz").<ref>{{Harvnb|Kinderman|1987|p=13}}</ref>

In liner notes to [[Vladimir Ashkenazy]]'s 2006 [[Decca Records|Decca]] recording, [[Michael Steinberg (music critic)|Michael Steinberg]] attempts to pinpoint what Beethoven might have found appealing in the theme, writing:

{{quote|Diabelli's theme is a thirty-two bar waltz laid out in symmetrical four-bar phrases and is almost tuneless, as though both hands were playing accompaniments. Midway through each half the harmony becomes slightly adventurous. Beginning with a perky upbeat and peppered with unexpected off-beat accents, its mix of neutrality and quirkiness makes it a plastic, responsive object for Beethoven's scrutiny. He had a lifelong fascination with variations and here he works with the structure, the harmonies, and piquant details more than with the surface of the theme, keeping the melody little in evidence.}}