Jump to content
Main menu
Main menu
move to sidebar
hide
Navigation
Main page
Recent changes
Random page
Help about MediaWiki
Special pages
Niidae Wiki
Search
Search
Appearance
Create account
Log in
Personal tools
Create account
Log in
Pages for logged out editors
learn more
Contributions
Talk
Editing
Felix Mendelssohn
(section)
Page
Discussion
English
Read
Edit
View history
Tools
Tools
move to sidebar
hide
Actions
Read
Edit
View history
General
What links here
Related changes
Page information
Appearance
move to sidebar
hide
Warning:
You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you
log in
or
create an account
, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
Anti-spam check. Do
not
fill this in!
==Reputation and legacy== ===The first century=== [[File:Mendelssohn Statue Thomaskirche.jpg|thumb|upright=0.8|alt=| The reconstructed Mendelssohn monument near Leipzig's [[St. Thomas Church, Leipzig|St. Thomas Church]], dedicated in 2008<ref name="City of Leipzig">{{cite web|title= Mendelssohn kehrt zurück Rekonstruiertes Denkmal am Dittrichring|url= https://www.leipzig.de/news/news/mendelssohn-kehrt-zurck-rekonstruiertes-denkmal-am-dittrichring/|publisher= City of Leipzig|language=de|access-date= 20 December 2017}}</ref>]] In the immediate wake of Mendelssohn's death, he was mourned both in Germany and England. However, the conservative strain in Mendelssohn, which set him apart from some of his more flamboyant contemporaries, bred a corollary condescension amongst some of them toward his music. Mendelssohn's relations with [[Hector Berlioz|Berlioz]], [[Franz Liszt|Liszt]] and others had been uneasy and equivocal. Listeners who had raised questions about Mendelssohn's talent included [[Heinrich Heine]], who wrote in 1836 after hearing the oratorio ''St. Paul'' that his work was <blockquote>characterized by a great, strict, very serious seriousness, a determined, almost importunate tendency to follow classical models, the finest, cleverest calculation, sharp intelligence and, finally, complete lack of naïveté. But is there in art any originality of genius without naïveté?{{sfn|Todd|1991|p=360}}{{sfn|Todd|2003|pp=448–449}}</blockquote> Such criticism of Mendelssohn for his very ability – which could be characterised negatively as facility – was taken to further lengths by [[Richard Wagner]]. Mendelssohn's success, his popularity and his Jewish origins irked Wagner sufficiently to damn Mendelssohn with faint praise, three years after his death, in an anti-Jewish pamphlet ''[[Das Judenthum in der Musik]]'':{{sfn|Conway|2012|p=263}} <blockquote>[Mendelssohn] has shown us that a Jew may have the amplest store of specific talents, may own the finest and most varied culture, the highest and tenderest sense of honour – yet without all these pre-eminences helping him, were it but one single time, to call forth in us that deep, that heart-searching effect which we await from art [...] The washiness and the whimsicality of our present musical style has been [...] pushed to its utmost pitch by Mendelssohn's endeavour to speak out a vague, an almost nugatory Content as interestingly and spiritedly as possible.{{sfn|Wagner|1995|pp=93–95}}{{refn|Echoes of such views survive today in critiques of Mendelssohn's alleged mediocrity. For a modern example see [[Damian Thompson]], [https://web.archive.org/web/20101113061710/http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/culture/damianthompson/100048736/why-did-mendelssohn-lose-his-mojo/ "Why did Mendelssohn lose his mojo?"], ''[[The Daily Telegraph]]'' 11 November 2010, retrieved 25 September 2017).|group=n}}</blockquote> The philosopher [[Friedrich Nietzsche]] expressed consistent admiration for Mendelssohn's music, in contrast to his general scorn for "Teutonic" Romanticism: <blockquote>At any rate, the whole music of romanticism [e.g. Schumann and Wagner] ... was second-rate music from the very start, and real musicians took little notice of it. Things were different with Felix Mendelssohn, that halcyon master who, thanks to his easier, purer, happier soul, was quickly honoured and just as quickly forgotten, as a lovely ''incident'' in German music.{{sfn|Nietzsche|2002|p=138}}</blockquote> Some readers, however, have interpreted Nietzsche's characterization of Mendelssohn as a 'lovely incident' as condescending.{{sfn|Todd|2001|loc=§14}} In the 20th century the [[Nazi Germany|Nazi regime]] and its ''[[Reichsmusikkammer]]'' cited Mendelssohn's Jewish origin in banning performance and publication of his works, even asking Nazi-approved composers to rewrite incidental music for ''A Midsummer Night's Dream'' ([[Carl Orff]] obliged).<ref>{{cite web|title= Music and the Holocaust: Carl Orff|url= http://holocaustmusic.ort.org/politics-and-propaganda/third-reich/orff-carl/|publisher= World ORT|access-date= 3 December 2017}}</ref> Under the Nazis, "Mendelssohn was presented as a dangerous 'accident' of music history, who played a decisive role in rendering German music in the 19th century 'degenerate'."<ref>{{harvtxt|Hansen|Vogt|2009}}, cited on web page of [http://www.mlgk.de/veranstaltungen/bloodandspirit.html Martin Luther Memorial Church, Eisenach] {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120402183805/http://www.mlgk.de/veranstaltungen/bloodandspirit.html |date=2 April 2012 }}</ref> The [[Mendelssohn Scholarship#Mendelssohn Scholarship in Germany|German Mendelssohn Scholarship]] for students at the Leipzig Conservatoire was discontinued in 1934 (and not revived until 1963). The monument dedicated to Mendelssohn erected in Leipzig in 1892 was removed by the Nazis in 1936. A replacement was erected in 2008.<ref name="City of Leipzig"/> The bronze statue of Mendelssohn by [[Clemens Buscher]] outside the Düsseldorf Opera House was also removed and destroyed by the Nazis in 1936. A replacement was erected in 2012. Mendelssohn's grave remained unmolested during the Nazi years.<ref>{{cite web|title= Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy – The Jewish Question|url= http://www.classicfm.com/composers/mendelssohn/guides/felix-mendelssohn-bartholdy-jewish-question|publisher= [[Classic FM (UK)|Classic FM]]|access-date= 20 December 2017}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title= Mendelssohn's statue returns to Düsseldorf|url= http://www.classical-music.com/news/mendelssohn%E2%80%99s-statue-returns-d%C3%BCsseldorf|publisher= Classical-music.com ([[BBC Music Magazine]])|access-date= 20 December 2017|archive-date= 24 December 2017|archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20171224124558/http://www.classical-music.com/news/mendelssohn%E2%80%99s-statue-returns-d%C3%BCsseldorf|url-status= dead}}</ref> Mendelssohn's reputation in Britain remained high throughout the 19th century. Prince Albert inscribed (in German) a libretto for the oratorio ''Elijah'' in 1847: "To the noble artist who, surrounded by the [[Baal]]-worship of false art, has been able, like a second Elijah, through genius and study, to remain true to the service of true art."{{sfn|Mercer-Taylor|2000|p=200}} In 1851 an adulatory novel by the teenaged [[Elizabeth Sara Sheppard]] was published, ''[[Charles Auchester]]''.<ref>{{cite book|last= Sheppard|first= Elizabeth|title= Charles Auchester|url= https://archive.org/details/charlesauchester00shep_841|publisher= A.C. McClurg and Co.|location= Chicago|year= 1891|oclc= 2327181}}</ref> The book features as its leading character the "Chevalier Seraphel", an idealized portrait of Mendelssohn, and remained in print for nearly 80 years.{{sfn|Conway|2012|p=257}} In 1854 Queen Victoria requested that [[the Crystal Palace]] include a statue of Mendelssohn when it was rebuilt.{{refn|It was the only statue in the Palace made of bronze and the only one to survive the 1936 fire that destroyed the Palace. The statue is now situated in [[Eltham College]], London.{{sfn|Eatock|2009|p=120}}|group=n}} Mendelssohn's "Wedding March" from ''A Midsummer Night's Dream'' was played at the wedding of Queen Victoria's daughter, [[Empress Frederick|Princess Victoria, The Princess Royal]], to [[Frederick III, German Emperor|Crown Prince Frederick William of Prussia]] in 1858, and it remains popular at marriage ceremonies.{{sfn|Emmett|1996|p=755}} Mendelssohn's pupil Sterndale Bennett was a major force in British musical education until his death in 1875, and a great upholder of his master's traditions; he numbered among his pupils many of the next generation of English composers, including Sullivan, [[Hubert Parry]] and [[Francis Edward Bache]].{{sfn|Firman|2004|p=}} By the early twentieth century, many critics, including [[George Bernard Shaw|Bernard Shaw]], began to condemn Mendelssohn's music for its association with Victorian cultural insularity; Shaw in particular complained of the composer's "[[wikt:kid gloves|kid-glove]] gentility, his conventional sentimentality, and his despicable oratorio-mongering".{{sfn|Todd|2003|p=6}} In the 1950s the scholar [[Wilfrid Mellers]] complained of Mendelssohn's "spurious religiosity which reflected the element of unconscious [[hypocrisy|humbug]] in our morality".{{sfn|Mellers|1957|p=31}} A contrasting opinion came from the pianist and composer [[Ferruccio Busoni]], who considered Mendelssohn "a master of undisputed greatness" and "an heir of Mozart".<ref>[[Andrew Porter (music critic)|Andrew Porter]], Liner notes to [[Walter Gieseking]]'s recording of Mendelssohn's ''Songs without Words'', Angel 35428.</ref> Busoni, like earlier virtuosi such as Anton Rubinstein<ref>See Rubinstein's concert programmes in {{harvtxt|Barenboim|1962}}, ''passim''</ref> and Charles-Valentin Alkan,{{sfn|Smith|2000|pp=97, 99}} regularly included Mendelssohn's piano works in his recitals. ===Modern opinions=== [[File:Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy - Friedrich Wilhelm von Schadow 1834.jpg|thumb|left|Felix Mendelssohn by [[Friedrich Wilhelm Schadow]], 1834]] Appreciation of Mendelssohn's work has developed since the mid-20th century, together with the publication of a number of biographies placing his achievements in context.<ref>e.g. {{harvp|Werner|1963}}, {{harvp|Mercer-Taylor|2000}}, {{harvp|Brown|2003}}, {{harvp|Todd|2003}}</ref> Mercer-Taylor comments on the irony that "this broad-based reevaluation of Mendelssohn's music is made possible, in part, by a general disintegration of the idea of a musical canon", an idea which Mendelssohn "as a conductor, pianist and scholar" had done so much to establish.{{sfn|Mercer-Taylor|2000|p=205}} The critic [[H. L. Mencken]] concluded that, if Mendelssohn indeed missed true greatness, he missed it "by a hair".<ref>quoted in {{harvnb|Todd|2001|loc=§14}}</ref> [[Charles Rosen]], in a chapter on Mendelssohn in his 1995 book ''The Romantic Generation'', both praised and criticized the composer. He called him "the greatest child prodigy the history of Western music has ever known", whose command at age 16 surpassed that of Mozart or Chopin at 19, the possessor at an early age of a "control of large-scale structure unsurpassed by any composer of his generation", and a "genius" with a "profound" comprehension of Beethoven. Rosen believed that in the composer's later years, without losing his craft or genius, he "renounced ... his daring"; but he called Mendelssohn's relatively late Violin Concerto in E minor "the most successful synthesis of the Classical concerto tradition and the Romantic virtuoso form". Rosen considered the "Fugue in E minor" (later included in Mendelssohn's Op. 35 for piano) a "masterpiece"; but in the same paragraph called Mendelssohn "the inventor of religious [[kitsch]] in music". Nevertheless, he pointed out how the dramatic power of "the juncture of religion and music" in Mendelssohn's oratorios is reflected throughout the music of the next fifty years in the operas of Meyerbeer and [[Giuseppe Verdi]] and in Wagner's ''[[Parsifal]]''.{{sfn|Rosen|1995|pp=569–598}} A large portion of Mendelssohn's 750 works still remained unpublished in the 1960s, but most of them are now available.<ref>[https://www.mendelssohn-stiftung.de/en/felix-mendelssohn-bartholdy/werkverzeichnis/ Mendelssohn Foundation website, "List of Mendelssohn's Works"] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170209210841/https://www.mendelssohn-stiftung.de/en/felix-mendelssohn-bartholdy/werkverzeichnis/ |date=9 February 2017 }} (in German). Retrieved 17 December 2017.</ref> A scholarly edition of Mendelssohn's complete works and correspondence is in preparation but is expected to take many years to complete, and will be in excess of 150 volumes. This includes a modern and fully researched catalogue of his works, the [[Mendelssohn-Werkverzeichnis]] (MWV).<ref>[http://www.saw-leipzig.de/forschung/projekte/leipziger-ausgabe-der-werke-von-felix-mendelssohn-bartholdy Official site] of the Leipzig Edition of Mendelssohn {{in lang|de}}. Retrieved 16 December 2017.</ref> Mendelssohn's oeuvre has been explored more deeply.{{refn|See, for example, the [https://jewishstudies.asu.edu/elijah conference "Viewing Mendelssohn, Viewing Elijah"] held at [[Arizona State University]] in 2009 to mark the composer's bicentenary. Accessed 12 September 2021.|group=n}} Recordings of virtually all of Mendelssohn's published works are now available, and his works are frequently heard in the concert hall and on broadcasts.<ref>For example, five of his works feature in the British radio station [[Classic FM (UK)|Classic FM]]'s 2017 [http://www.halloffame.classicfm.co.uk/composers?page=16 top 300] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120305144729/http://www.halloffame.classicfm.co.uk/composers?page=16 |date=5 March 2012 }}. Retrieved 16 December 2017.</ref> R. Larry Todd noted in 2007, in the context of the impending bicentenary of Mendelssohn's birth, "the intensifying revival of the composer's music over the past few decades", and that "his image has been largely rehabilitated, as musicians and scholars have returned to this paradoxically familiar but unfamiliar European classical composer, and have begun viewing him from new perspectives."{{sfn|Todd|2007|p=xi}} {{Clear}}
Summary:
Please note that all contributions to Niidae Wiki may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see
Encyclopedia:Copyrights
for details).
Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!
Cancel
Editing help
(opens in new window)
Search
Search
Editing
Felix Mendelssohn
(section)
Add topic