Editing Otto Rank (section)

== Post-Vienna life and work ==
In May 1926, having made the feeling relationship in the "here-and-now" central to his practice of psychotherapy, Rank moved to Paris where he became a psychotherapist for artists such as [[Henry Miller]] and [[Anaïs Nin]] and lectured at the [[University of Paris|Sorbonne]] (Lieberman, 1985).

Nin was transformed by her therapy with Rank. On her second visit to Rank, she reflects on her desire to be "re-born," feelingly, as a woman and artist. Rank, she observes, helped her move back and forth between what she could verbalize in her journals and what remained unarticulated. She discovered the quality and depth of her feelings in the wordless transitions between what she could say and what she could not say. "As he talked, I thought of my difficulties with writing, my struggles to articulate feelings not easily expressed. Of my struggles to find a language for intuition, feeling, instincts which are, in themselves, elusive, subtle, and wordless" (Nin, 1966, p. 276).

According to Rank, all feelings are grounded in the present. In ''Will Therapy,'' published in German in 1929–31, Rank uses the term "here and now" for the first time in the psychotherapeutic literature: "Freud made the repression historical, that is, misplaced it into the childhood of the individual and then wanted to release it from there, while as a matter of fact the same tendency is working here and now" (Rank, 1929–31, p. 39). 

Instead of the word "Verdrängung" ("repression"), which laid stress on unconscious repression of the past, Rank preferred to use the word "Verleugnung" ("denial"), which focused instead on the emotional will to remain ill in the present: "The neurotic lives too much in the past [and] to that extent he actually does not live. He suffers … because he clings to [the past], wants to cling to it, in order to protect himself from experience [''Erlebnis''], the emotional surrender to the present" (Rank, 1929–31, p. 27).

In France and later in America, Rank enjoyed great success as a therapist and writer from 1926 to 1939. Traveling frequently between France and America, Rank lectured at universities such as [[Harvard University|Harvard]], [[Yale]], [[Stanford University|Stanford]], and [[University of Pennsylvania]] on relational, experiential and "here-and-now" psychotherapy, art, the creative will, and "neurosis as a failure in creativity" (Rank, 1996).

Just as [[Erik Erikson]] was the first analyst to focus on identity and adulthood, Rank was the first to propose that separation from outworn thoughts, feelings and behaviors is the quintessence of psychological growth and development. In the late 1920s, after he left Freud's inner circle, Rank explored how human beings can learn to assert their will within relationships, and advocated a maximum degree of individuation (or "difference") within a maximum degree of connectedness (or "likeness"). Human beings need to experience ''both'' separation and union, without endlessly vacillating between the two poles.

Foreshadowing the central themes of [[Jean Piaget|Piaget]], [[Lawrence Kohlberg|Kohlberg]], [[James McClelland (psychologist)|McClelland]], [[Erik Erikson|Erikson]] and [[Robert Kegan]], Rank was the first to propose that human development is a lifelong construction, which requires continual negotiation and renegotiation of the dual yearnings for individuation and connection, the will to separate and the will to unite. Decades before [[Ronald Fairbairn]], now credited by many as the inventor in the 1940s of modern object-relations theory, Rank's 1926 lecture on "The Genesis of the Object Relation" marks the first complete statement of this theory (Rank, 1996, pp. 140–149). 

By 1926, Rank was persona non grata in the official psychoanalytic world. There is little reason to believe, therefore, that any of the other writers credited with helping to invent object relations theory ([[Melanie Klein]] or [[Donald Winnicott]], for example) ever read the German text of this lecture, published as ''Zur Genese der Object-beziehung'' in Vol. 1 of Rank's ''Genetische Psychologie'' (1927, pp. 110–122).

Rank died in New York City in 1939 from a kidney infection, one month after Freud's physician-assisted suicide on the [[Yom Kippur|Jewish Day of Atonement]]. ''"Komisch"'' (strange, odd, comical), Rank said on his deathbed (Lieberman, 1985, p. 389).