Editing Blind Harry (section)

==''Acts and Deeds''==
{{original research|section|date=August 2021}}

===Sources===
Blind Harry claimed his work was based on a book by Father John Blair, Wallace's boyhood friend and personal [[chaplain]]. This book has not been seen in modern times and may never have existed; the poet's attribution of his story to a written [[text (literary theory)|text]] may have been a literary device; many contemporary critics believe that ''Acts and Deeds'' is based on [[oral history]] and the national [[tradition]]s of Blind Harry's homeland.

Most historians nowadays regard ''Acts and Deeds'' as a versified [[historical novel]], written at a time of strong anti-English sentiment in Scotland. At twelve volumes, the work is also doubted to be solely his work. Elspeth King maintained that despite any inaccuracies, Harry's patriotic and nationalistic portrayal was to ensure Wallace's continuing reputation as a hero. [[Robert Burns]] acknowledged his debt to Harry, paraphrasing the following lines from Harry's ''Wallace'' in his own poem [[Scots Wha Hae|Robert Bruce's Address to his Army at Bannockburn]] (Scots, wha hae wi' Wallace bled):<br />
<blockquote>A false usurper sinks in every foe<br />
And liberty returns with every blow</blockquote>
which Burns described as "a [[couplet]] worthy of [[Homer]]".

The earliest version of the work is found in a manuscript written in 1488 by John Ramsay, the purported scribe of [[John Barbour (poet)|John Barbour's]] narrative poem ''[[The Brus]]''. The manuscript is found at the [[National Library of Scotland]] in [[Edinburgh]].<ref>{{cite book|title=The Oxford Companion to English Literature|editor-first=Margaret|editor-last=Drabble|year=1985|page=453}}</ref>

===Criticism===
Harry's depiction of Wallace has been criticised by Major and others as being fictionalized. Some parts of it are at variance with contemporary sources, ''e.g.'', the work describes Wallace leading an army to the outskirts of London, and it includes some episodes of doubtful accuracy before Wallace enters history with the [[action at Lanark]]. It also describes him adopting the disguises of a monk, an old woman, and a potter while a fugitive, and travelling to France to enlist support for the Scottish cause, there defeating two French champions, as well as a lion.  "Are there any more dogs you would have slain?", Wallace asks the French king.

Harry is often considered inferior to [[John Barbour (poet)|Barbour]] as a poet, and has little of his moral elevation, but he surpasses him in graphic power, vividness of description, and variety of incident. He occasionally shows the influence of [[Geoffrey Chaucer|Chaucer]], and is said to have known Latin and French.

Blind Harry's words were made more accessible by a translation written by [[William Hamilton of Gilbertfield]] (c. 1665–1751) published in 1722. In this form they met the notice of poets such as [[Robert Burns]], [[Lord Byron]], [[Robert Southey]], [[John Keats]], [[Joanna Baillie]], and [[William Wordsworth]]. It was also an important source for [[Randall Wallace]] in his writing of the screenplay of ''[[Braveheart]]'', the award-winning Hollywood film.<ref name = anderson>Anderson, Lin. ''Braveheart: From Hollywood to Holyrood''. Luath Press Ltd. (2005), p.&nbsp;27.</ref> Most recently, in 1998, Elspeth King published Hamilton's text amended for modern readers as ''Blind Harry's Wallace''.

===Wallace folklore===
Blind Harry mentions a number of battles or skirmishes fought by Wallace which are now regarded by historians as unhistorical.  These battles are sometimes referenced as historical events by accounts which do not cross-check the stories in ''Acts and Deeds'' against another source.  Dubious battles include the "Battle of [[Loudoun Hill]]" in 1296, the "Battle of [[Biggar, South Lanarkshire|Biggar]]" in 1297, and possibly also the "Battle of Elcho Park". In the case of the folkloric Battle of Loudoun Hill, later [[enthusiast]]s have erected a monument to Wallace at the site. (The folkloric battle should not be confused with the genuine [[Battle of Loudoun Hill]] fought by [[Robert the Bruce]].) Similarly, the story of a [[Barns of Ayr|mass hanging of Scots nobles]] at Ayr is described by Blind Harry, and is repeated in a number of places, including the film ''[[Braveheart]]'', but is now regarded as unhistorical.