Editing Natural transformation (section)

===Example: dual of a finite-dimensional vector space===
Every finite-dimensional vector space is isomorphic to its dual space, but there may be many different isomorphisms between the two spaces. There is in general no natural isomorphism between a finite-dimensional vector space and its dual space.<ref>{{harv|Mac Lane|Birkhoff|1999|loc=§VI.4}}</ref> However, related categories (with additional structure and restrictions on the maps) do have a natural isomorphism, as described below.

The dual space of a finite-dimensional vector space is again a finite-dimensional vector space of the same dimension, and these are thus isomorphic, since dimension is the only invariant of finite-dimensional vector spaces over a given field. However, in the absence of additional constraints (such as a requirement that maps preserve the chosen basis), the map from a space to its dual is not unique, and thus such an isomorphism requires a choice, and is "not natural". On the category of finite-dimensional vector spaces and linear maps, one can define an infranatural isomorphism from vector spaces to their dual by choosing an isomorphism for each space (say, by choosing a basis for every vector space and taking the corresponding isomorphism), but this will not define a natural transformation. Intuitively this is because it required a choice, rigorously because ''any'' such choice of isomorphisms will not commute with, say, the zero map; see {{harv|Mac Lane|Birkhoff|1999|loc=§VI.4}} for detailed discussion.

Starting from finite-dimensional vector spaces (as objects) and the identity and dual functors, one can define a natural isomorphism, but this requires first adding additional structure, then restricting the maps from "all linear maps" to "linear maps that respect this structure". Explicitly, for each vector space, require that it comes with the data of an isomorphism to its dual, <math>\eta_V\colon V \to V^*</math>. In other words, take as objects vector spaces with a [[nondegenerate bilinear form]] <math>b_V\colon V \times V \to K</math>. This defines an infranatural isomorphism (isomorphism for each object). One then restricts the maps to only those maps <math>T\colon V \to U</math> that commute with the isomorphisms: <math>T^*(\eta_{U}(T(v))) = \eta_{V}(v)</math> or in other words, preserve the bilinear form: <math>b_{U}(T(v),T(w))=b_V(v,w)</math>. (These maps define the ''naturalizer'' of the isomorphisms.) The resulting category, with objects finite-dimensional vector spaces with a nondegenerate bilinear form, and maps linear transforms that respect the bilinear form, by construction has a natural isomorphism from the identity to the dual (each space has an isomorphism to its dual, and the maps in the category are required to commute). Viewed in this light, this construction (add transforms for each object, restrict maps to commute with these) is completely general, and does not depend on any particular properties of vector spaces.

In this category (finite-dimensional vector spaces with a nondegenerate bilinear form, maps linear transforms that respect the bilinear form), the dual of a map between vector spaces can be identified as a [[transpose]]. Often for reasons of geometric interest this is specialized to a subcategory, by requiring that the nondegenerate bilinear forms have additional properties, such as being symmetric ([[orthogonal matrices]]), symmetric and positive definite ([[inner product space]]), symmetric sesquilinear ([[Hermitian space]]s), skew-symmetric and totally isotropic ([[symplectic vector space]]), etc. – in all these categories a vector space is naturally identified with its dual, by the nondegenerate bilinear form.