Jump to content
Main menu
Main menu
move to sidebar
hide
Navigation
Main page
Recent changes
Random page
Help about MediaWiki
Special pages
Niidae Wiki
Search
Search
Appearance
Create account
Log in
Personal tools
Create account
Log in
Pages for logged out editors
learn more
Contributions
Talk
Editing
Greed (1924 film)
(section)
Page
Discussion
English
Read
Edit
View history
Tools
Tools
move to sidebar
hide
Actions
Read
Edit
View history
General
What links here
Related changes
Page information
Appearance
move to sidebar
hide
Warning:
You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you
log in
or
create an account
, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
Anti-spam check. Do
not
fill this in!
===Initial editing=== Editing ''Greed'' took almost a year and von Stroheim's contract did not include payment for his post-production work.{{sfn|Weinberg|1972|p=15}} He and his chief film cutter Frank Hull worked on the film for several months before completing a rough cut.{{sfnm|1a1=Finler|1y=1972|1p=29|2a1=Koszarski|2y=1983|2p=326}} Von Stroheim was indecisive during editing. He felt restricted by his contract's limitation on the length of the film.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=140}} Von Stroheim colored certain scenes with gold tinting by using the [[Handschiegl Color Process]], in which individual frames are hand colored with stencils.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=147}} Von Stroheim credited himself in the beginning titles with "Personally directed by Erich von Stroheim."{{sfn|Rosenbaum|1993|p=41}} Other than studio personnel, only twelve people saw the original 42-reel{{efn|It is traditional to discuss the length of theatrical motion pictures in terms of "[[Reel#Motion picture terminology|reels]]". The standard length of a 35 mm motion picture reel is {{convert|1000|ft|m|abbr=off|sp=us}}. This length runs approximately 11 minutes at sound speed (24 frames per second) and slightly longer at silent film speed (which may vary from approximately 16 to 22 frames per second). Therefore the 42-reel version of ''Greed'' was 462 minutes (8 hours) at 24 fps, 551 minutes (9 hours) at 20 fps and longer at other speeds.}} version of ''Greed'' at a special screening in January 1924;{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=29}} they included [[Harry Carr]], [[Rex Ingram (director)|Rex Ingram]], [[Aileen Pringle]], [[Carmel Myers]], [[Idwal Jones (academic)|Idwal Jones]], Joseph Jackson, Jack Jungmeyer, Fritz Tidden, Welford Beaton, Valentine Mandelstam, and [[Jean Bertin]].{{sfn|Weinberg|1972|p=13}} After the screening Jones, Carr and Ingram all agreed that they had just seen the greatest film ever made and that it was unlikely that a better film would ever be made.{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=14}} Carr wrote a review of the advance screening where he raved that he "saw a wonderful picture the other day—that no one else will ever see ... I can't imagine what they are going to do with it. It is like ''[[Les Miserables]]''. Episodes come along that you think have no bearing on the story, then 12 or 14 reels later it hits you with a crash. For stark, terrible realism and marvelous artistry, it is the greatest picture I have ever seen. But I don't know what it will be like when it shrinks to 8 reels."{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} [[Jonathan Rosenbaum]] suggested that Carr was most likely referring to a cut sequence early in the film that introduced all of the characters who lived in McTeague's building. The forty-minute scene depicted what the tenants did on a Saturday afternoon, and established cinematic atmosphere without furthering the plot. Rosenbaum compared the cut sequence to novels of the 19th century and to the first few hours of [[Jacques Rivette]]'s ''[[Out 1]]''.{{sfn|Rosenbaum|1993|p=29}} Jones publicly praised the advance screening and compared ''Greed'' to ''[[The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari]]'' and ''[[Dr. Mabuse the Gambler]]''.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} However, Welford Beaton of ''The Film Spectator'' disliked the 42-reel version and criticized its excessive use of close-ups.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} [[File:Greed, 1924, 10.1 rapacità.jpg|thumb|left|Some scenes, like this one, were [[Handschiegl Color Process|gold tinted]] by von Stroheim himself, hand coloring individual frames with stencils.]] Many sources claim that the 42-reel version was only ever intended to be a rough cut,{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} and that Von Stroheim chose to cut it down to 24 reels by March 18, 1924,{{sfn|Wakeman|1987|p=1074}}{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=142}} with the intention of screening it with intermissions over two nights.{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=18}} The director had difficulty cutting the film down, telling his friend Don Ryan, "I could take out sequences and thus get the job over in a day. That would be child's play. But I can't do it. It would leave gaps that could only be bridged through titles. When you do such a thing you have illustrated subtitles instead of a motion picture."{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} Von Stroheim later claimed that at this time the Goldwyn Company wanted him to shoot a scene of McTeague waking up in his dentist chair, showing the entire film to have been a bad dream.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=141}} While von Stroheim was editing the 24-reel cut June Mathis, who was the head of the Goldwyn Story Department, had made her own 13-reel version of ''Greed'' by January 21, 1924. She ordered even more cuts to be made on January 29, but then left for Rome in early February to oversee the production of ''[[Ben-Hur (1925 film)|Ben-Hur]]'' and was uninvolved in the film's editing for several months.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=144}} After having completed the 24-reel{{efn|264 minutes (4 hours and 24 minutes) at 24 fps and 315 minutes (5 hours and 15 minutes) at 20 fps.}} cut of ''Greed'', von Stroheim told Goldwyn executives that he could not cut another frame.{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=18}} Goldwyn producers thought that this version was still too long and told him to cut it to a more manageable length. Von Stroheim then sent the film to his friend, director Rex Ingram, who turned it over to his editor, [[Grant Whytock]].{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=18}} Whytock had worked with von Stroheim on ''[[The Devil's Pass Key]]'' and was familiar with the director's style and tastes. Whytock initially proposed that it be split in two, with one 8-reel film ending with the wedding and a second 7-reel film ending at Death Valley. Whytock eventually cut the film down to 18 reels.{{efn|198 minutes (3 hours and 18 minutes) at 24 fps and 236 minutes (3 hours and 56 minutes) at 20 fps.}} His only major cut was the entire subplot of Zerkow and Maria, which he thought was "very distasteful".{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=143}} Otherwise he simply cut down scenes and cut out {{convert|1,200|ft|m|sigfig=1}} of quick "flash" shots that only lasted a few frames. However, Whytock's version of ''Greed'' retained the prologue and other subplots, as well as much of the humor that was later cut out of it.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=143}} Whytock and Ingram screened their version of ''Greed'' to studio executives, who responded favorably to it but worried that the tragic ending would be hard to sell to the public.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|p=144}} Ingram then sent the 18-reel version to von Stroheim and told him, "If you cut one more frame I shall never speak to you again."{{sfn|Finler|1972|p=28}} On April 10, 1924, the Goldwyn Company officially agreed to merge with Metro Pictures, putting von Stroheim's nemesis Thalberg directly in charge of ''Greed''.{{sfn|Koszarski|1983|pp=142–143}} Von Stroheim and [[Louis B. Mayer]] had a lengthy confrontation over the film's editing, which according to both men ended with von Stroheim claiming that all women were whores and Mayer punching him.{{efn|In a remarkably similar story, screen actor [[John Gilbert (actor)|John Gilbert]] once told Mayer that his own mother was a whore and Mayer allegedly chased him with a knife.{{sfn|Flamini|1994|pp=85-86}}}}{{sfn|Rosenbaum|1993|p=38}} Mayer disliked the film because of its lack of glamor, optimism, or morality and considered it to be a guaranteed flop.{{sfn|Curtiss|1971|p=178}}
Summary:
Please note that all contributions to Niidae Wiki may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see
Encyclopedia:Copyrights
for details).
Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!
Cancel
Editing help
(opens in new window)
Search
Search
Editing
Greed (1924 film)
(section)
Add topic